Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin (2022) s01e04 Episode Script

No, my mom would kill me.
God, Angela, just have some gum later.
Don't worry. You'll get used to it.
- Hey!
- Oh shit, Angela. Hold this.
You girls smokin' back here?
Not me. Just her. Right, Angela?
Marjorie, get the hell outta here.
You, come with me.
Come on, Angela, don't be mad.
Look, I got you something
as a thank you.
Are we friends, Marjorie?
No phones in detention.
I'm sorry, Mrs. Murray,
but it's my doctor.
I have to take this.
Thank you.
Mr. Thompson, thanks so
much for calling me back.
Happy to chat,
though I'm not sure
I can be much help.
I wasn't really in your
mother's friend group.
What about Angela Waters?
She was also a classmate of yours.
What would I know about Angela Waters?
I'm trying to talk to as many people
from your graduating
class as possible
for a school project.
Were my mom and Angela friends?
Look, I don't
- know anything about Angela.
- No
So sorry. I can't help you.
Shit.
- Thank god that's over.
- No shit.
Two weeks of detention is
nothing after juvie, but still.
It was lucky. We were lucky.
So, what happens now?
What do you mean?
- I go back to "Swan Lake."
- And I go back to training,
counting the minutes till
my ankle monitor comes off.
Are you asking about
"A," Mouse?
It's been two weeks and
no more psychotic texts.
- Maybe he's moved on?
- What about our moms?
Are we never gonna tell
them what happened to Karen?
- Or to us?
- Not until we know more about
what really went down
with Angela Waters.
It's weird. I've
been putting out calls,
but no one wants to talk about her.
It's like she's a ghost
or an urban legend.
And you still think Angela Waters
is somehow connected to A?
All of our moms knew her,
and we're their daughters.
There must be a reason
A is targeting us.
And the mystery continues.
Good luck with that.
Crap, I have to go back.
I gotta get something from the A/V room.
You guys go ahead. It
might take me a minute.
Okay. Bye.
Hello? Anyone in here?
Get off me!
Shut the fuck up, Ty.
Dude, what? She did. She came twice.
Trish is a fucking nymphomaniac.
I'm not talkin' about
Trish. I'm talkin' about you.
Dude, I came twice, too.
But I never pulled
out. I just stayed inside of her.
Yo, get over yourself, bruh.
Trish is like the
doorknob of Millwood High.
We've all had our turn.
- I have some exciting news.
- Hm.
This lovely couple
put an offer on your house, Imogen.
Really?
Already?
But what about all our stuff?
I was gonna bring a crew in.
Pack things up, clean the house.
Can I do it?
Sure.
We have a little time.
Class, for this assignment,
you'll be partnering up.
Together, you'll choose one of
the directors on my approved list,
select a scene from a
film in their catalog,
and recreate it.
But first, you'll pitch your vision
for the scene to the class.
Tell us what you want
to say with the piece,
why it's relevant today.
Kelly, are you switching dance lockers?
Yeah, I like Karen's better.
Faran, I'd like you to
do a series of one-on-ones
to get back up to speed with Kelly.
I'll get caught up, but
can't I work with Henry?
Kelly's sister just died.
She doesn't need more on her plate.
On the contrary. Kelly has
dedicated herself to "Swan Lake,"
and it's been, I think, a
welcome positive distraction.
So, I'm doing this not just for you,
though you need the help badly
but for her.
Be straight with me, Coach.
I'm weak.
- Slow, right?
- You're out of practice,
but we'll get you
back in fighting shape.
Like, the whole premise
of Spectrum is to be inclusive,
so you should come to a meeting.
Or we could just hang out at least.
Like, are you doing
anything for Halloween?
Usually I go to a midnight
movie at the Orpheum,
but I hear they're not
showing one this year.
- Your friend works there, right?
- Oh, yeah, Tabby.
She does. Um, want me to ask why not?
No, it's cool but, I am
in the mood to dress up.
I was thinking I'm
gonna be Ziggy Stardust
or Freddie Mercury.
I've heard of a few
parties we could crash.
Oh, no. My moms never let
me go out on Halloween.
"Too dangerous," they say.
I could come over.
We could hand out candy,
chill with your moms.
Oh, I would never
inflict that on anyone
but especially not you.
Let me see what I could
do about Halloween night.
I might be able to sneak out.
What do you think, Imogen?
- Is it all ours?
- It's all ours.
Do you wanna go upstairs?
- Yes!
- Okay.
Hello?
Anyone there?
Excuse me!
- Can I help you?
- Oh my gosh.
So sorry to bother
you. My husband and I,
we just put an offer on this
house, and we're so excited,
so we just came by to see it again.
And you're taking photos because?
To send to my folks.
Was this your house?
It still is my house.
Did the real estate agent
tell you what happened in it?
So, I heard from my buyers.
Why would you say those things, Imogen?
I just told them the truth
- that my mom died there.
- No.
You said that a woman
had been murdered there,
which is not the truth.
It's my house.
I hate the idea of
strangers living there.
Well, congratulations.
They're pulling their offer.
Guess it wasn't meant to be.
I wanted to spare you from this,
but your mother was in
a lot of debt, Imogen.
I was hoping a sale
would cover what she owed.
Also, I heard from one of my
old classmates, Don Thompson,
that you've been calling around,
and asking questions
about Angela Waters.
- Why would you be doing that?
- Because
There is a connection
between what happened
to Angela and what
happened to my mom,
and because you won't
tell us what it is.
Imogen, are you maybe wanting to
see something that isn't there?
Or are you trying to cover up
something that actually is there?
I want you to move on from all this.
It's a little harder for
me to move on, Ms. Hayworth.
- My mom is dead.
- I meant move on from Angela Waters.
What are you all hiding?
Why does no one want to
talk about Angela Waters?
You do need to move on, Imogen.
And your house needs to be sold,
so however else you
want to spend your time,
I'd finish picking out
what you want to save
and say goodbye.
- How about Sam Raimi?
- Mm.
We could do a scene
from "The Evil Dead."
Ugh, no. No way.
I thought you loved "Evil Dead."
It's just that scene
where the woods attack and
basically rape that one girl
ruins the whole movie for me.
It's, like, did that
really need to happen?
So, uh, no "Evil Dead."
Raimi's not even on Mr. Smithee's list,
but you know who is?
The Master of the Macabre himself.
Female victims murdered
by masked male psychopaths.
Violence perpetrated against
women's bodies by men,
the foundation of almost
every horror movie.
If you draw a line
backwards through time,
through all the iconic slasher movies
from "Scream" to "Halloween,"
it leads you back
to the ur-killing that started it all.
The shower scene from "Psycho."
I see. So, you're
going to put yet another
vulnerable young woman
in Norman Bates' cross hairs.
Funny how if there's gonna
be a naked murder victim,
people automatically assume
it's gonna be a woman.
But we're changing it up.
Our victim will be a
vulnerable young man.
Our murderer will be a woman.
Different genders,
different power dynamics,
and none of that trans-phobic
panic shit, either.
Horror from the point
of view of the female gaze.
Basically, it's a
contemporary feminist take
on the shower scene from "Psycho."
So, who's down to be my
modern-day Marion Crane?
Baby on board.
Plus, your mom's
actually gonna murder me
if I don't finish going through
all the stuff at my house.
Fair Mouse?
This might be a good
time to tell you that
I don't really like
horror movies. Sorry.
Also fair.
Noa!
When and where are you filming?
The boys' locker room.
It's part of my concept.
Principal Clanton gave
you permission to do that?
Nope. We're gonna have to
do it at night and break in.
Oh, a little B&E right
before getting my monitor off?
And then there was one
Faran?
If I agreed who's
the guy I'd be killing?
What about your ballet hottie?
Henry?
He's actually someone I
could see myself dating,
so I'd rather not stab him to death. No.
Okay. Well
this short is really,
really important to me.
I have to get it right.
So, I need a guy who isn't shy,
someone who won't balk
at being objectified.
The legend is back!
Yeah, boys! What's up?
Someone like?
Well, he's definitely done grieving.
- Hey, Greg. Got a second?
- Hayworth
What the fuck? You made
that video of Karen.
And it's truly the
biggest regret of my life.
I've got a few of those.
And I know she fucked
with you and your friends.
She did.
But still, no excuse.
Look, Greg, I'm making another video,
but don't worry, this
one's fully sanctioned.
Has anyone ever told you that
you look like Ryan Reynolds?
I saw you today showin'
off in the cafeteria.
- Have you ever thought about acting?
- I don't know. What's the movie?
It's for Mr. Smithee's class.
Have you ever seen Hitchcock's "Psycho"?
Girl stops at a motel, takes a shower,
guy comes in, kills
her, but I'm flipping it,
and I need a guy who's not shy,
confident in his own skin.
- Who else is in the movie?
- Faran Bryant.
And I kill her?
No She kills you.
But basically, it-it's a shower
scene with hot girl, right?
- Mm-hm.
- Sweet.
I'm in.
Excellent.
Nice extension.
I'm sorry we have to do this, okay?
Honestly, I have no idea why
Giry even asked me to help you.
I'm not as good of
a dancer as you are.
But that doesn't matter
because I have an asterisk by my name.
Asterisk, Faran Bryant,
the only reason she got
cast as the Black Swan
is because she's Black.
At least that's
what your sister said.
But
she didn't actually use that word,
- did she?
- Wow, Kelly
I thought Karen was the gas
lighting microaggressor, not you.
That wasn't just in my head.
Now, as to why you're coaching me
Giry also feels sorry for
you 'cause your sister died.
So, let's just get
through this, all right?
Look
we don't have to practice together.
I'll just go do my thing, and
you just be a queen, girl.
You just be a queen, girl.
You must be keen to get your ankle
monitor off later this week, huh?
I said, "Are you keen?"
I am.
- Yeah, yes.
- But I'm not done with you yet.
If you meet the requirements
of your probation
for one year exactly,
your record will be wiped clean.
Otherwise, there will
be consequences.
You've been quiet,
Noa. Everything okay?
Yeah. It's just
Sheriff Beasley's riding
my ass to the bitter end.
That asshole.
If he only knew the truth, right?
Shawn, don't start up
with that again, please.
You're not even
supposed to know about
What really happened?
I'm sorry, but it's shitty that
you're dealing with any of this
when the person who's
really to blame is
Hey, honey.
Hey, hey, Shawn.
I got off early. Thought we
could go to a movie maybe?
Shawn, you're welcome to join us.
Nah, I'm good, um.
I should be getting home
anyway, but you guys go.
I'll talk to you later, babe.
- One more game?
- Yes, but a different one.
Do you believe in ghosts?
Hey.
Can we hang out after school
tomorrow with the girls?
A Losers Club reunion? I'm down.
We're not shooting till
Wednesday night. What's up?
I thought, maybe
we could try to contact my mother.
Hey, did you tell Kelly
that the only reason
she's coaching you is
because her sister died?
Why would you do that?
Because, Henry, unlike everyone else,
I cannot pretend that
I suddenly like Kelly.
I'm not wired that way. Sorry.
How about just having sympathy for her?
It's hard to muster sympathy
for someone coaching you
- when they're not even a good dancer.
- I disagree.
While you were in detention,
I worked with Kelly every day
and she's gotten better. A lot better.
It's almost like I'm
dancing with Karen again.
Like Karen? In what way?
Just can you cut her some slack?
I'm sorry, Kelly, about how
I acted at our last sesh.
I was out of line, and
I'm sorry about Karen.
I haven't even said that to you yet.
Thank you.
I appreciate that.
You must really miss her a lot.
It's
hard to even think about, honestly.
I remember reading this article
about twins once and it said that
sometimes when something
bad happens to one twin,
a trauma of some kind,
the other one can feel it, too.
- It was a little bit like that, yeah.
- Yeah.
You'd do pretty much
anything for each other.
I mean, would've done anything
back when Karen was alive.
Yes.
I mean
- yeah, she was my
- Soul mate?
Best friend, I was gonna say.
Yeah, that's her leotard
you're wearing, isn't it?
Maybe we should get started.
Absolutely.
Um, I guess I'll start.
We're, um
gathered here to make contact
with the spirit of Davie Lee Adams
my mom.
Mom
it's me
Imogen.
I guess what I really want to know is
are you okay?
Or at peace?
Who's moving it?
- I-I'm not doing it.
- Uh, don't look at me.
Everyone, take your hands off.
Mom
what happened to you?
Did you
Did you die alone?
Or is there someone else with you?
Did it have something
to do with Angela Waters?
Please.
I need to know.
There has to be an explanation.
Why would you leave me?
If you really did
kill yourself out of guilt,
then you had to have known that
I'd be the one to find you in the tub
and deal with all this bullshit.
Alone.
Seriously? You have nothing to say?
After everything that you have
put me through, you abandoned me.
I have no one
and nothing.
Say something.
Please.
It is the least that you could do.
- Imogen
- Let her work it out.
You know what, Mom?
Fuck you!
I hate you!
And you wanna know what else?
I'm glad that this place is selling
because I don't wanna
think about you anymore.
Can we please get the
fuck out of here? Please?
Yes.
But, you're wrong
- about having no one.
- Yeah you have us.
We're here for you, Imogen.
For sure. We are.
To quote "Chucky"
"Friends till the end."
Yeah.
How can we help you, Sheriff?
Terms of your probation
allow me to make unscheduled
drop-ins and searches.
Yeah, but you haven't
done any this whole time.
I'll start in your bedroom.
Bathroom?
- What are these?
- They're not mine.
They're magnesium to help me sleep.
Oh my god. I got them from
the school nurse. Ask her.
What a psycho.
What's in your bag, Mom?
You using again?
I sometimes take a quarter
Oxy for my back pain
but that's it.
These aren't even yours.
Are you excited?
- For what?
- Are you kidding?
Today is your last day
wearing that ankle monitor.
Um, yeah. Guess I'll be
more excited tomorrow.
So, how do we even get
into the building tonight?
Uh, me. I'm gonna hang out after school
at the A/V studio,
and then at 9:00, I'll meet
everyone at the side door.
It's a quick setup. We should be
shooting by 10, done by midnight.
And let me stress,
this is a somewhat intimate scene,
so I wanna make sure everyone
feels safe and supported,
and that we're in control.
You've got my shot list
and the storyboards I drew,
so there shouldn't be surprises.
Any questions?
What are you using for blood,
and am I getting any on me?
Hm, Hitchcock used Hershey syrup.
We're using corn syrup
mixed with red food coloring,
and no, like in the original,
the violence will be
implied more than shown.
Too bad, 'cause I'm always down
for a meaningful
exchange of bodily fluids.
Okay, Greg, that is exactly
the kind of bullshit I
don't wanna hear on my set.
- What about our costumes?
- We will have them waiting for you.
Full Marion Crane.
- I have to wear a costume?
- You're wearing a Speedo.
That makes zero sense. I wouldn't
be showering with a Speedo on.
We're not gonna see the Speedo.
We're shooting around it.
The nudity, like the
violence, will be suggested.
Any other questions?
Yeah, in case this turns into a porno,
are you guys providing the condoms
or should I bring my own?
- Oh my god.
- What the actual fuck?
I'm just messin' around. I hear you.
Okay? Safe set, promise.
Thank you.
Moving on.
I have a surprise for you.
When I was your
age, I wrote everything down.
Hm. So do I right before I post it.
This is for you and nobody else.
Every girl has her secrets.
If you spark to it, I'll
get you another one, okay?
And if you're like me,
you'll have them for life.
Thanks for doing this.
I'm happy for the distraction.
Is Kelly being awful?
Let's just say she's
giving off some serious
Karen vibes.
Mm.
Can I share kind of a crazy theory
with you about Kelly being K
Hey, guys.
Never mind. It's too crazy.
- Sorry, sorry.
- Ladies first.
Yeah, half pepperoni, half cheese.
How long will that be?
Great, thanks.
- How was that?
- Good, but we're gonna go again,
and this time what I'm
looking for is your intention.
I want to see it in your eyes.
Hitchcock was all about the eyeballs.
- My intention being?
- You had dinner with Norman.
You're attracted to him, aroused by him,
so in true slasher fashion,
you're gonna penetrate him.
Oh, with your knife.
You're gonna stab him.
- Got it.
- All right, back to one.
And rolling.
And action.
And cut!
Ooh, that was awesome!
It gave me literal chills.
Now, you can relax
and we're gonna move
on to Greg's coverage.
What am I supposed to
be doing? Just showering?
For context, you just
had dinner with Marion.
She gave you wine,
but didn't have any herself.
Maybe she even slipped
something into your drink.
You're vulnerable.
- A damsel in distress.
- Yeah, right. A damsel?
And then, Greg, while
you were just showering,
we are going to be
breaking the last taboo.
- What's the last taboo?
- Oh, it's nothing bad.
We're just going to
show a hot male body
namely yours
violated by a female phallus Faran's!
- I'm gonna need like five.
- Five and we'll go.
So, if we start on this
shot, we can move to this shot
and then I won't have to change the
lighting setup until we get down here.
- Um
- Oh my god.
He's totally naked.
Where's your damn Speedo, Greg?
It was uncomfortable. It
was tugging at my balls.
- And isn't it more authentic this way?
- Why do you always
- have to be such a fucking clown?
- I didn't hear you complaining
when you asked me to
be in your little movie.
And what the hell did
I say at our meeting?
That I wanted a safe set.
You naked, not safe, not cool.
I don't mind personally,
and like you said, I'm
not shy because there is
- no reason to be.
- Oh!
- Plus, I gave up carbs for this, so.
- It's not about you!
- It's disrespectful to your costar!
- Yo, Faran, you mind?
Ballet's a lot raunchier than this.
We won't see anything on camera.
We should roll soon, though.
It's gettin' kinda late.
Let's take another five.
- Tabby, Tabby, where you goin'?
- For a walk.
You're okay.
You're okay. You're okay. You're okay.
You're okay.
Chip, what's going on?
Oh, hey. Everything okay? You good?
I-I'm fine. Where are Faran and Greg?
Oh, they just, they just left.
But we barely got half the scene.
I didn't know where you were,
- and you weren't answering your phone.
- I didn't have my phone.
Yeah, I know. It's here.
But Faran and Greg
were gettin' kinda cold,
and wanted to go home,
so I finished the scene.
What do you mean? You shot it?
Yeah, but d-don't worry.
I followed the storyboards exactly.
Is that not okay?
No, it's fine.
Okay.
Yes?
Pizza delivery.
Finally. Come on up.
Actually, uh, my car is running, so
Jesus. I'll be right down.
Help! Help! Help!
Help!
Fuck you!
Why don't you come and
get me, you little bitch?!
What do you want?!
Just tell me!
Punish the guilty.
The guilty?
- Who's guilty?
- Your mother.
Millwood General
Hospital, how may
I direct your call?
Security, please.
One moment.
Security?
One of your nurses
Marjorie Olivar
has been stealing drugs
from the hospital pharmacy.
Come again?
Check her purse.
Thanks for meeting me, Henry.
Sure. What's up?
I need your help
and I didn't want to ask over text.
- Ooh, mysterious.
- This is gonna sound crazy,
but what if Karen's not really dead?
Faran, we were at the
dance. We all saw her fall.
Yeah, but what if that wasn't Karen?
What if it was Kelly?
They switched places and pretended
to be each other all the time.
- Faran, this is deranged.
- You're the one who said it, Henry.
"It's like dancing with Karen."
Yes, like dancing with Karen,
not actually dancing with Karen.
It's other things, too. Little clues.
But I figured out a way to be sure.
Remember the razorblades
in Karen's pointe shoes?
Yeah?
If I'm right,
and Kelly is actually Karen,
she'd have some kind of scar.
And you want me to
do your dirty work and check?
All you have to do is offer to
give her a foot rub during PT.
And if there's no scar?
I'll let it go.
Promise.
I found my mom's diaries. All of them.
- What do they say?
- It's what they don't say.
This one's from our moms' senior year.
The entries slow down
to a trickle, then stop,
- but before that
- Some of the pages are torn out.
Exactly. Why would a girl rip
out pages from her own diary?
I mean, the whole point is
that it's private, right?
Unless there was something so bad
she wanted to rip it out of
existence, even for herself.
And what, you think
she destroyed the pages?
Or they're hidden? Maybe
somewhere in my house.
Jesus, what happened to you?
Did you get your ankle monitor off?
I did this morning.
Guys
A's back.
And he came after me in
person to my building.
- Why you?
- According to the text he sent,
because of something my
mom did to Angela Waters.