Mr. Mercedes (2017) s03e05 Episode Script
Great Balls of Fire
1 Previously on "Mr.
Mercedes" I would've thought she'd be back by now.
She didn't even pack up her shit.
Not even a note.
- You really loved her.
- I just don't get it.
My focus is whether you'll be able to contribute meaningfully to your own defense.
Uh, yeah.
Ms.
Linklatter, you have been found competent.
It is therefore your legal right to have your day in court.
"With public sentiment on one's side, nothing can fail.
" Brady say that, did he? The public is gonna set me free.
I got a high school buddy, Andy Halliday, runs an old bookstore.
Well, some kid came into the bookstore asking about Rothstein that kid! That's the Saubers family.
Pete, we got another envelope this morning.
$9,000.
Where'd you get the money? It's not coming from me.
May I ask a question? Are we on a date? Would you like it to be? Everybody I touch suffers.
You're really worried about her, Lou.
She's fucked.
- My doing.
- Not everything is your doing.
But this one is.
I wanna call Holly as a witness.
She could be a De facto surrogate.
"If you like Holly, wait till you see Lou.
" What is this that I can't see With icy hands taking hold on me I am death and none can excel I'll open the doors to heaven or hell Oh, death Oh, death Can't you spare me over till another year? - Oh, death - Give it up, Billy boy.
- Oh, death - Throw in the towel.
Okay? You don't have what it takes.
You never did.
Someone would pray, couldn't you call You're not here.
No.
I'm dead.
But clearly, not gone.
And that's your fear, isn't it? Once you're dead, gone, gone, gone, gone.
But the fear that's under that one let's call it, uh, totem pole fear is that you were never there in the first place.
You got no legacy.
You think finding my killer is gonna give you one? Well, let me tell you something, bud.
Legacy is shit.
And shit don't mean shit.
Thank you.
So, like, Scrooge and shit? - What? - Like, like, Charles Dickens, the ghost of Scrooge, Christmas past, and shit? Along the lines.
Fuck.
Banging on about legacy and all this.
Maybe he's right.
You ever think about getting psychological help or something? My insurance doesn't cover it, so I gotta slum it and talk to you.
Are we anywhere at all? We're waiting on the DNA on the hospital guy.
I sent you the composite sketch.
We're gonna release it to the public tonight.
So you're basically still nowhere.
It's a process.
You got your process and we got ours, except ours doesn't involve ghosts.
I take you into confidence and you mock me.
- I'm not mocking you.
- Yes, you are.
I'm not mocking you.
Look.
I'm just I'm just saying that if we're gonna solve this, we're gonna have to do it right here on Earth.
Hi, this is Danielle.
Leave a message after the beep.
Can you at least let me know you're okay? Regardless of whether you forgive me or wanna get back, or Fuck, Danielle.
This is not fair.
Just let me know.
What are you doing, Mom? Hey.
You've been going on about these for over a year.
I had to see what all the fuss was about You went into my room? What do you mean, did I go into your room? Who do you think changes your sheets and does your laundry? These are my books.
Hey.
I thought you'd be pleased.
I spent my day trying to understand my self-centered and pretentiously intellectual son with a C average at school.
God, honey, these books are not that good.
The only one that shows any promise is this last one, - but he doesn't even - The last one? Where he goes into advertising? Where Rothstein sold him out? A writer is more of a secretary than God, so Rothstein didn't do anything to Jimmy Gold.
What Rothstein saw and allowed Jimmy to show us is that most of us just become everyman.
Ordinary, we just - morph into the guy next door.
- No.
Yeah, honey.
Jimmy Gold evolved into bland nothingness.
I just snapped.
One second, she was talking shit about Jimmy Gold.
The next, I had her by the throat.
What stopped you? I don't know.
I just let go of her.
Anything more from your friend, the book dealer? Has the kid come back? Not to my knowledge.
He said he'd call me if he returned.
Well, we can't just wait.
Maybe the kid did come back, with the books, which your high school buddy bookstore friend now has - and is maybe trying to sell.
- That didn't happen.
Why, 'cause your buddy didn't call you to give you the big heads-up? We're talking about millions of dollars here.
You need to go see your friend.
Meanwhile, I'm gonna pay a visit to Peter Saubers' mother.
What's the pretext? My cat.
You don't have a cat.
You hate cats.
She doesn't.
I agree.
Lou is shaky.
This is a total crapshoot.
One we have to take.
She's talking about Brady, you know.
Not listening to him.
Him is Brady.
I know that.
I'm not stupid.
Then there's Holly, like, and the wheels on her bike aren't exactly fastened tight.
I'll handle Holly.
And how do we go about managing that? I'm sorry? I know what's going on or what's on the precipice of going on with you two.
She's a fragile person.
Meaning what? Meaning you need to tread careful.
She's precious cargo.
Right now, we should just be focusing on the case.
Yeah, well, Holly's the star witness.
I am talking about the case still, technically.
Were you just talking about me? I have kind of a sixth sense for when people are talking about me.
Well, maybe you need to focus on the other senses, some of which could use some tweaking.
He projects his anxiety when he's nervous.
Hey.
Uh, so I've got something on the father, Carl Fenten.
Evidently, the mother is dead, but apparently, he has a auto repair shop here in Bridgton.
- That's the address.
- Goody.
Yeah.
How's Lou? She ready? Mm.
That's a great job.
Well done.
- Thank you.
- Let's go.
Good luck.
Thanks.
- Not a peep? - Not yet.
Hmm.
Wow, and he's never called you again? Why you so interested in this kid, Morris? I'm not interested in the kid.
I'm interested in Rothstein.
Now that he's dead, his stuff is worth who knows how much.
I never knew you to be a collector.
I mean, I know how much you love Jimmy Gold and all that, but to take it to the level of collector takes money, Morris.
You come into some money? If I had money, I'd be going to legitimate bookstores.
Instead, I've come to you.
I'm offended by that.
Give me a break, Andrew.
You buy and sell stolen books.
Everybody knows it.
Are you telling me that the police haven't come calling, asking you whether anybody's tried to unload a Rothstein? Yeah, the police came once.
You've now come twice and called twice.
You seem especially interested.
My one chance in life to get my hands on an original why wouldn't I be? 'Kay.
- If the kid comes back - Yeah.
Or anybody else, for that matter I'll call.
So, Morris.
What're you what're you up to these days? What're you into? Excuse me? Well, we're old buddies.
We should catch up more.
Word is that you and Alma Lane have been spending some quality time.
Are you fucking that old battleaxe again? If I were, it'd be none of your fucking business.
Sure would be a curious thing, though.
Rothstein fucked her.
You fucked her.
Forgive me.
I'm just a sucker for coincidence.
Good.
Be seated.
You okay? Fine.
You seem a bit fidgety.
I'm fine.
I'm a fidgety person.
It's not gonna be today, you know.
Like, the prosecution has to make its case first.
- So you got time.
- Okay.
I'm fine.
I'm a fidgety person.
I'm allowed to be a fidgety person.
Good morning, everyone.
Good morning.
Good morning, Ms.
Pace.
Mr.
Finkelstein.
- Ms.
Linklatter.
- Morning.
And I-I just want to remind you all again that this might look and walk and quack like a circus, but it's a courtroom.
It's my courtroom.
Wheels of justice - Get on with it, for fuck's sake.
- The whole ten yards.
Fucking blowhard.
Ms.
Pace? You have the honor.
Thank you, Your Honor.
The People call William Hodges.
Excuse me.
Mr.
Hodges is not on their witness list.
- He's on yours.
- What's going on? - I'm calling my first witness.
- Objection.
All right, approach the bench.
This is not a nice fucking start.
Are you kidding me? He's on the list.
There's no unfair surprise here.
- This is bullshit.
- Bullshit is in play here.
He plans to backdoor jury nullification, and we all know it.
You need to rethink this, young lady.
It's all rethought.
Detective Hodges was in the room.
He was there.
He's a material eyewitness.
- And now he's here.
- I want time to prep him.
You mean coach him? - Fuck you.
- Fuck you.
Fuck both of you.
This is not a goddamn good start.
You got five minutes.
- Your Honor - That's it.
He can take a breath.
He can have a moment.
He can take a dump.
But he's in that chair in five minutes.
You got that? You wanted to see me? Oh, Peter.
Yes, come in.
Is there something wrong? Not at all.
This is one of the very best student papers I've read in quite a long time.
Really? Because it was so confident.
Thank you.
Hang on a sec.
Would you sit? Did you write it? Of course I did.
It's just that You have never written anything like this.
Well, to be honest, I've never really loved the books in your class till this one.
Well, I'm not sure I agree with your conclusions.
You say that Jimmy is a noble American hero, but is that really supported by the concluding book in the trilogy? Jimmy's still a rebel in the end.
Why? Because he throws an ashtray through a TV screen? That's a symbol.
Tell me.
The CBS logo is an eye, and Jimmy's act is a ritual blinding of his inner eye, the one that sees the truth.
Well you really are a Rothstein man.
I'm impressed.
But in your paper, you you don't talk about how he died.
- No.
- Well, I have to wonder why.
I mean, this just happened.
It wouldn't have fit the theme, and just to die like that At least Rothstein's major work was done.
Unless you're one of those people who believe he was still writing, and that he left this trove of treasures.
Well, I'd really love to read those if that's true.
Mm-hmm.
I gotta go to class, um You swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God? - I do.
- Be seated.
Mr.
Hodges.
Ms.
Pace.
You're a retired detective with the Bridgton Police Department? I am.
You were the lead detective tasked with investigating the jobs fair massacre, perpetrated by Brady Hartsfield.
I was.
You retired from the force, having made no arrest on the case, but you had occasion to pursue the matter as a private detective.
I did.
Would it be fair to say that you were consumed with bringing Mr.
Hartsfield down? It would.
Fair to say you wanted Brady Hartsfield dead? I wanted justice, which he got.
When a criminal defendant is executed before he's brought to trial, that coincides with your notion of justice? There were extenuating circumstances here.
Which were? Brady Hartsfield nearly killed her.
The man was evil incarnate.
So if a criminal suspect is evil enough, you support a pre-trial execution? I'm sorry.
Has this witness been called to give testimony or opinion? Mr.
Hodges has a bias in favor of the defendant.
He's in fact a defense witness.
I'm therefore allowed to treat him as hostile and establish that bias.
Well, just get on with it then, please.
Brady Hartsfield, in addition to killing so many, killed someone you had personal feelings for.
Janey Patterson.
Is there a point? My point is that of all the people in this room wanting Mr.
Mercedes to get his just reward, no one would take a backseat to you.
Get on with it, Counsel.
You were there, weren't you, Mr.
Hodges? When Brady Hartsfield was assassinated? - You were sitting right in the room.
- I was.
Can you tell us what you observed? I saw Lou, after giving testimony, leave the witness box.
She approached Mr.
Hartsfield, whispered something in his ear, and produced a weapon, and she shot him.
In the head.
Well, she aimed for his nuts, but she missed.
Is this a joke to you? The joke is that Lou Linklatter is facing trial for performing two seconds of community service.
That's the joke.
After giving testimony, did you observe the defendant rush up to the victim, or did she walk calmly? The latter.
She seemed in control of her mental faculties from your vantage point? She did.
And given your own hatred, your rage towards Mr.
Hartsfield, I'm guessing you'd understand the defendant's fury toward her victim.
You covered that.
In fact, who among us, given the carnage caused by Brady Hartsfield, wouldn't want to blow that monster's head off? Trilogy now.
You've made that point three times.
If you had the chance, would you have killed him? Did you not hear my question, Detective? No, I heard the question.
It's hypothetical.
It's actually not hypothetical, because you had two such occasions to kill Brady Hartsfield, where in fact, you began to kill Brady Hartsfield, once in a hospital room when you pinched his oxygen line, the other in a cell when you grabbed him by the throat and began to strangle him.
In both cases, you stopped yourself, didn't you, Detective? I did.
Why? Don't much remember, truth be told.
That's not "truth be told.
" That's a lie.
You stopped yourself on both occasions because you did not want to sink to Brady Hartsfield's level.
You did not want to be lawless like him.
A mind-reader now.
Jack of all jack-offs.
I don't need to be a mind-reader, because you gave that exact statement to the police.
You even said to be rendered lawless means that Brady Hartsfield wins.
You did not want to give him that satisfaction the very satisfaction that Lou Linklatter gave him.
Your Honor, what is the point of this? Mr.
Hodges is not on trial here.
No, he's not, because he did not commit a homicide.
But he is here to give testimony in support of someone who did.
You're a unique witness in this case, Mr.
Hodges.
You know and care for the defendant.
You harbored a compulsion to get Mr.
Hartsfield, who, as you say, was evil.
You can appreciate the anguish of his victims, many of them with us here today.
You're unequivocally on the "hate Mr.
Mercedes" side of the fence.
But you are also a man of law and order.
You're a man who believes that this system needs to be one of integrity, so I'm going to finish here by asking you the toughest question of all, reminding you that you are under oath.
One hell of a windup.
As much as you understand why Lou Linklatter took the law into her own hands, do you really mean to sit in that chair and advocate on behalf of vigilantism? I'm here to advocate for Lou.
He stabbed her, for God's sake.
So eye for an eye.
That's where you stand? Is it your testimony that people, for the purpose of exacting revenge, should be allowed to take the law into their own hands? Thank you, Your Honor.
Let Lou go! Let Lou go! We love you! Let Lou go! Let Lou go! Over here! Detective Hodges! Why did Brady - Why did Lou kill Brady? - Detective Hodges! Let Lou go! Let Lou go! Let Lou go! Let Lou go! Thanks for all the help.
Sitting there like a fucking zombie.
Why didn't you say something? You could've established Brady was able to keep killing, - even in custody - The judge shut that down.
Slip it in sideways, for fuck's sake.
No, because if I even go near self-defense, I would be put in contempt of court.
- Do you understand that? - All the Cerebellin, medical wonder boy bullshit, the whole thing None of that negates that Lou executed him, and for us to try to deny that we will look like we're okay with murder! What's your plan? I've told you our plan.
Involuntary manslaughter.
It's a fine line one that I can walk.
- I don't fucking think so.
- Okay, stop it, both of you.
I have to be off to see Carl Fenten's dad.
Maybe you can go and get yourself a law degree or something.
- I'll see you back at the office - Fuck off.
Fuck off yourself.
See you back in the office.
Did it go that badly? Not at all.
No new information came in.
He came off sympathetic to Lou, which the jury saw.
He's just not the cleanup hitter that we hoped.
- Right.
- It's all going to come down to Lou's testimony anyway, and yours.
Right.
Holly.
If you don't feel up to it No, I have to be up to it.
I will just ask questions.
And you just give honest answers.
You just just be yourself.
'Kay.
Yeah.
I can't be bothered To miss you anymore It's month 12, day 31, and hour 24 I used to think Shit, shit, shit.
- Is he in trouble? - Not at all.
Then I don't understand.
The crash site was less than a mile from here.
Peter has been known to walk the area.
It's possible he came upon the wreckage.
But he didn't.
He would've told us.
There was money, we think, in the car, possibly connected to the John Rothstein murder.
It's possible some of Rothstein's merchandise, manuscripts, even, were in the wreckage.
And it's possible somebody came upon the crash site, found the money and merchandise, and absconded with it.
You think Peter did this? We're talking to everybody in the vicinity.
How has Peter seemed recently? How has he seemed? Mrs.
Saubers, we're really not trying to be antagonistic.
Okay, you are in my home, asking questions about my son and whether or not he's in possession of stolen property.
What is that if not antagonistic? And what about your husband? Where is he? He's in court.
Court? The trial for the woman who killed Mr.
Mercedes.
My husband was crippled at the jobs massacre.
We noticed, uh, he recently leased some space on Center Street.
Yes.
He used to be a real estate broker before the accident, and he's decided to get back into it.
It's not cheap leasing space right on Center Street.
Did he come into some money recently? An inheritance, maybe? Don Fenten? You a cop? May I have a word, please? My son was a dope.
He was good at driving cars, which is why I think he was chosen to do something way, way over his head.
He didn't kill Rothstein.
How can you know that? My son didn't own a gun.
You check his priors, robbery, yes, but never armed robbery.
It just wasn't in Carl.
The other guy killed Rothstein.
Had to be.
Well, let's turn to the other guy.
You can't conceive who it might be? Somebody dominant.
Somebody alpha.
I don't think he had any idea what he was getting himself into.
It might help if you could visit her before court.
In lockup? Oh, it'd have to be lockup.
They're not gonna let her out to make a burger run.
- If you'd rather not, though - No, I can do it.
Holly I admit I'm a little torn.
I'm duty-bound to protect Lou's constitution any way I can if she becomes unhinged.
But I also worry about your own emotional footing.
I don't know how to be.
Well, as I said, you just be yourself, and I'll just ask the questions No, I don't mean in court.
I mean, right now.
I don't know how to be sitting in a car with you.
You're scared I might try to kiss you or something? No.
Well, yeah.
- N-no.
- Oh, so we're clear, then? No, I'm I I am afraid that you'll kiss me.
I'm terrified of it, but I also want to kiss you.
But what I want is way trumped by fear.
Terror.
You may be the most honest person I've ever met.
See, and that terrifies me because it was sweet, you know, it was nice in a path-to-intimacy kind of way.
That makes me need to pee.
Sorry.
Okay.
- Look.
- Mm-hmm? I'm not going to kiss you tonight.
But I don't want you to fear the future.
I'm just gonna show you what it would be like so you'll be less terrified of it.
How was it? It was really, really good.
I mean, albeit in a short and uneventful way.
Wait, can you put me on the stand still now that you kissed me, though? I can.
'Kay.
I don't know why I asked.
Suspected something how? I don't know.
He just seemed suspicious.
Curious as to my interest in Rothstein, - even though he's known forever - And the Saubers kid hasn't been back to the bookstore? - Not once? - So he says.
I wonder.
Police being at the Saubers house obviously, we're not the only ones sniffing this kid.
I'm almost rooting for the cops at this point.
Excuse me? If they find those books, you know, I won't get rich, but at least I'll get to read them, maybe.
My God.
That's really what it's about with you, isn't it? Getting to read those books.
I have to see what he became.
I have to know.
I'm gonna try again tomorrow with the mother.
Hopefully, the cops won't be there.
Who are you texting? Danielle.
I still don't get it.
Gone.
Whoosh.
Fucking nothing.
Morris, I'm gonna ask you an honest question, and I want an honest answer.
What? I think it's sweet that you miss your twitty little Danielle.
That's your question? No, my question is, when you fuck me, do you think of that twitty little thing? 'Cause that would not be good.
You're being disgusting.
I don't give a shit.
When a man's in me, he better be all in.
You're going to court tomorrow, by the way.
Court? Why? Because I have an idea.
Don't fucking lie to me, Peter! - I'm not fucking lying.
- Bullshit! - Tom! - He's lying to me.
Bullshit.
Peter, there was money in the car, right? Huh? There were probably Rothstein books as well.
I've got anonymous cash donations showing up at this house in the mail.
You are all into fucking John Rothstein.
- The cops are knocking at the door.
- Dad, Dad, Dad, they're teaching Rothstein in school.
Who the fuck isn't reading Rothstein - Bullshit.
He's lying to me.
- Tom.
Peter.
We are honest people, okay? We may not have much, but we have that.
We are honest people.
Peter, just tell us.
Are you in trouble? I'm not in trouble.
I wanna see those books you got from the library.
- I returned them.
- See? He's fucking lying, Marjorie.
Fuck off! What did you say to me? - You say that to me one more time.
- You wanna fight.
- No! Don't you dare! - You say that to me one more fucking time.
Fuck you! The defense essentially planned to use Hodges as kind of a secret weapon, but the district attorney let the air out of their tires.
You could practically see that big man deflate with a big hiss.
Hey! You're on the TV.
Nobody can call you ordinary now.
You fucked your friend Lou, haven't found my killer, talked about on television you are a spectacular failure.
Nothing spectacular about it.
They only put ordinary failures on TV nowadays.
It makes the ads look better.
Well, there's no such thing as bad publicity, bud.
I mean, "I never miss a chance "to have sex or be interviewed on the TV.
" When did you say that? Gore Vidal said that.
Jesus Christ, bud, you never read anybody but me? Not Gore fucking Vidal, I'll tell you that much.
You spoke to me like you knew who I am, who I was Can I tell you a secret? I never spoke to you.
You're speaking to me now.
You are speaking to you now.
Okay.
If you're so smart, tell me this.
Is Brady Satan? Satan? Brady, Satan? There is no Satan.
Oh, my God.
Satan's a human creation.
He's like God or Cheez Whiz, or, you know Billy, I think you're missing the point.
There's only one way out, and that's in.
Hello? Hello? - Hi.
- Hi.
Ooh, it's a little poochy.
Poochy! What a beautiful dog.
Oh, you whoo! He likes me.
My name is Alma Lane and I am so sorry to disturb you, but my cat, Carleton, he's gone missing, and I'm passing out some flyers.
This is my little Carleton - a bit of a wanderer.
- Usually, I'm not concerned, but it's been over a week now.
Have you seen him? I'm sorry, no.
It's just not like him to stay away this long.
Are you all right, dear? I'm fine.
Why are you staring at me? Oh, I don't mean to.
I'm sorry.
Truth be told, I'm a little psychic.
I walked up here worried about my cat.
Now I'm a little worried about you.
You need to be pretty.
And not too twitchy.
I don't find you twitchy in a bad way, but I need you to be comfortable in your own skin in a way that in a way that I can't.
What? Why are you looking at me like that? I'm worried about you.
You seem erratic.
Yeah, well, I'm on trial for my life, and your boss? He didn't exactly carry the day on my behalf.
Well, I mean, he was a little boxed in by the truth.
Oh, yeah? What about you? I'll need to tell the truth as well.
You and I, we're Brady bashers.
I shot him.
And you oh, girl.
You just Your job is to show the jury that Brady-bashing oh.
It's such a good thing.
Brady-bashing is sympathetic and so pretty.
You have a very odd tone, Lou.
I'm a little uneasy.
I'm gonna be sounding real good when I'm out, though.
She's getting worse.
And the way she talks is how Brady would talk.
I mean, not that I ever spoke with Brady, you know.
I did.
You're not wrong.
He's in her head somehow.
What do we do? First of all, whatever we can to get her out.
- After that - Mr.
Hodges.
Yeah? Sorry to intrude.
I just wanted to say a quick thank you.
My name's Morris Bellamy.
I was at the jobs fair that night one of the lucky ones.
Hello.
Hi.
So many of us are so grateful to both of you.
And I'm not sure it gets said quite enough, so I thought I'd say it.
- Thank you.
- Thank you, both of you.
Again, sorry to intrude.
Wait just a second.
You were one of Brady Hartsfield's victims? Well, emotionally.
I escaped physical harm.
Thank God.
Where's your head at on this? I'm sorry? This trial.
Do you want to see Lou Linklatter convicted or set free? Lou Linklatter's a hero in my book.
Did you have an opportunity to speak with her after? I did.
And did she tell you where she procured the 3-D revolver? She told me she made it herself.
Is that easy to do? No.
There's a fair amount of engineering expertise involved.
Premeditation.
Coherent thinking.
Malice aforethought.
That was all part of the mix of what you observed, was it not, Mr.
Montez? - Objection, foundation.
- Lay opinion.
Move it along.
As you observed the defendant shoot Brady Hartsfield, she appeared to be acting calmly, willfully, and with purpose? Appeared to be the case.
And was Brady Hartsfield posing a threat to anybody when Lou Linklatter acted to end his life? No.
She executed him.
Appeared to be the case.
Thank you, Mr.
Montez.
You swore to tell the truth.
I did.
But you have an even higher obligation to tell it, don't you? You're a prosecutor, an officer of the court.
My obligation is the same as any other witness.
As an Ohio prosecutor, do you know and understand Ohio criminal law? Well, that would be the goal.
Before the shooting, would you say Brady Hartsfield seriously provoked my client? Not in court, not on that day.
In the months leading up to the event, when he attacked her, when he almost killed her, almost killed thousands of people, would you say he provoked her? That's fair.
Did his provocation cause my client to suffer great mental or emotional distress, if you know? Cause her to fear for her life? Cause her to lose sleep, weight, hopes I can't argue with any of that.
A person in Ohio can't be convicted of both murder and manslaughter for the same killing.
No.
It's one or the other.
Because not all killings are the same.
Murder is worse than manslaughter.
When you saw my client shoot Mr.
Mercedes, did you think to yourself, "That woman is a murderer"? I'm not sure I was thinking about it in those terms.
Well, you're a trained prosecutor.
You must've had some opinion, some reaction.
- Objection.
- Sustained.
Seeing a man killed is upsetting.
- It is.
- So is testifying.
Upsetting, scary, nerve-racking for everybody, even you.
You you're not enjoying this.
No.
Did you know how having to give testimony would affect her that day? I didn't realize the extent, no.
Do you make room for the possibility, Mr.
Montez, that having been assaulted by Brady Hartsfield, nearly killed by him in the most vicious way, being stabbed in the stomach, and then having to be in a room with him to face him down do you make room for the possibility that it was just all too much for Lou Linklatter? Is it possible? Of course it's possible.
Thank you.
Calm, coherent, deliberate, reflective, with malice aforethought.
You still stand by that testimony? - I do.
- Thank you, Your Honor.
What do you think? I don't know.
It's close.
Could be bad.
It's hard to be objective.
My testimony could be very important.
You like him, don't you? What? Finkelstein.
You like him.
I do.
What do you think of him? He seems good.
I think it went as well as we can hope.
But you want me to plead.
Well, I'm not saying We're gonna win.
I know it.
Is that what he's telling you? 'Cause he's misled you before.
He's a very complicated person.
He really is.
He hurts me, and then he helps me, and then he hurts me.
All I gotta do is know which one is which.
You made contact? Both with him and the woman, Holly Gibney.
Step one.
Mission accomplished.
Excellent.
What about you and the Saubers mother? Contact also established.
Minimal, but progress.
I'll get inside that family.
It's only a matter of time.
I can tell you this.
She's freaked about something, and it wasn't my lost cat.
Where are you now? Doing a little spring cleaning on the chance the police come sniffing my way.
Gotta make sure there's nothing for 'em to find.
Why would they be coming your way? Hopefully, they won't.
But, Morris, we both entered into the mix.
And that composite they released didn't look a whole lot like you, but I'm not taking any chances.
Your bookstore buddy could connect the dots.
True.
I'll call you when I'm done here.
Don't tell me not to live Just sit and putter Life's candy and the sun's a ball of butter Don't bring around a cloud to rain on my parade Don't tell me not to fly, I've simply got to If someone takes a spill, it's me and not you! Who told you you're allowed to rain on my parade? I'll march my band out I'll beat my drum And if I'm fanned out Your turn at bat, sir At least I didn't fake it Hat, sir, I guess I didn't make it But whether I'm the rose of sheer perfection A freckle on the nose of life's complexion The cinder or I'll march My band out I'll beat My drum And if I'm fanned out Your turn at bat, sir At least I didn't fake it, hat, sir I guess I didn't make it Get ready for me, love, 'cause I'm a comer I simply gotta march, my heart's a drummer Nobody, no Nobody Is gonna Rain on my Parade
Mercedes" I would've thought she'd be back by now.
She didn't even pack up her shit.
Not even a note.
- You really loved her.
- I just don't get it.
My focus is whether you'll be able to contribute meaningfully to your own defense.
Uh, yeah.
Ms.
Linklatter, you have been found competent.
It is therefore your legal right to have your day in court.
"With public sentiment on one's side, nothing can fail.
" Brady say that, did he? The public is gonna set me free.
I got a high school buddy, Andy Halliday, runs an old bookstore.
Well, some kid came into the bookstore asking about Rothstein that kid! That's the Saubers family.
Pete, we got another envelope this morning.
$9,000.
Where'd you get the money? It's not coming from me.
May I ask a question? Are we on a date? Would you like it to be? Everybody I touch suffers.
You're really worried about her, Lou.
She's fucked.
- My doing.
- Not everything is your doing.
But this one is.
I wanna call Holly as a witness.
She could be a De facto surrogate.
"If you like Holly, wait till you see Lou.
" What is this that I can't see With icy hands taking hold on me I am death and none can excel I'll open the doors to heaven or hell Oh, death Oh, death Can't you spare me over till another year? - Oh, death - Give it up, Billy boy.
- Oh, death - Throw in the towel.
Okay? You don't have what it takes.
You never did.
Someone would pray, couldn't you call You're not here.
No.
I'm dead.
But clearly, not gone.
And that's your fear, isn't it? Once you're dead, gone, gone, gone, gone.
But the fear that's under that one let's call it, uh, totem pole fear is that you were never there in the first place.
You got no legacy.
You think finding my killer is gonna give you one? Well, let me tell you something, bud.
Legacy is shit.
And shit don't mean shit.
Thank you.
So, like, Scrooge and shit? - What? - Like, like, Charles Dickens, the ghost of Scrooge, Christmas past, and shit? Along the lines.
Fuck.
Banging on about legacy and all this.
Maybe he's right.
You ever think about getting psychological help or something? My insurance doesn't cover it, so I gotta slum it and talk to you.
Are we anywhere at all? We're waiting on the DNA on the hospital guy.
I sent you the composite sketch.
We're gonna release it to the public tonight.
So you're basically still nowhere.
It's a process.
You got your process and we got ours, except ours doesn't involve ghosts.
I take you into confidence and you mock me.
- I'm not mocking you.
- Yes, you are.
I'm not mocking you.
Look.
I'm just I'm just saying that if we're gonna solve this, we're gonna have to do it right here on Earth.
Hi, this is Danielle.
Leave a message after the beep.
Can you at least let me know you're okay? Regardless of whether you forgive me or wanna get back, or Fuck, Danielle.
This is not fair.
Just let me know.
What are you doing, Mom? Hey.
You've been going on about these for over a year.
I had to see what all the fuss was about You went into my room? What do you mean, did I go into your room? Who do you think changes your sheets and does your laundry? These are my books.
Hey.
I thought you'd be pleased.
I spent my day trying to understand my self-centered and pretentiously intellectual son with a C average at school.
God, honey, these books are not that good.
The only one that shows any promise is this last one, - but he doesn't even - The last one? Where he goes into advertising? Where Rothstein sold him out? A writer is more of a secretary than God, so Rothstein didn't do anything to Jimmy Gold.
What Rothstein saw and allowed Jimmy to show us is that most of us just become everyman.
Ordinary, we just - morph into the guy next door.
- No.
Yeah, honey.
Jimmy Gold evolved into bland nothingness.
I just snapped.
One second, she was talking shit about Jimmy Gold.
The next, I had her by the throat.
What stopped you? I don't know.
I just let go of her.
Anything more from your friend, the book dealer? Has the kid come back? Not to my knowledge.
He said he'd call me if he returned.
Well, we can't just wait.
Maybe the kid did come back, with the books, which your high school buddy bookstore friend now has - and is maybe trying to sell.
- That didn't happen.
Why, 'cause your buddy didn't call you to give you the big heads-up? We're talking about millions of dollars here.
You need to go see your friend.
Meanwhile, I'm gonna pay a visit to Peter Saubers' mother.
What's the pretext? My cat.
You don't have a cat.
You hate cats.
She doesn't.
I agree.
Lou is shaky.
This is a total crapshoot.
One we have to take.
She's talking about Brady, you know.
Not listening to him.
Him is Brady.
I know that.
I'm not stupid.
Then there's Holly, like, and the wheels on her bike aren't exactly fastened tight.
I'll handle Holly.
And how do we go about managing that? I'm sorry? I know what's going on or what's on the precipice of going on with you two.
She's a fragile person.
Meaning what? Meaning you need to tread careful.
She's precious cargo.
Right now, we should just be focusing on the case.
Yeah, well, Holly's the star witness.
I am talking about the case still, technically.
Were you just talking about me? I have kind of a sixth sense for when people are talking about me.
Well, maybe you need to focus on the other senses, some of which could use some tweaking.
He projects his anxiety when he's nervous.
Hey.
Uh, so I've got something on the father, Carl Fenten.
Evidently, the mother is dead, but apparently, he has a auto repair shop here in Bridgton.
- That's the address.
- Goody.
Yeah.
How's Lou? She ready? Mm.
That's a great job.
Well done.
- Thank you.
- Let's go.
Good luck.
Thanks.
- Not a peep? - Not yet.
Hmm.
Wow, and he's never called you again? Why you so interested in this kid, Morris? I'm not interested in the kid.
I'm interested in Rothstein.
Now that he's dead, his stuff is worth who knows how much.
I never knew you to be a collector.
I mean, I know how much you love Jimmy Gold and all that, but to take it to the level of collector takes money, Morris.
You come into some money? If I had money, I'd be going to legitimate bookstores.
Instead, I've come to you.
I'm offended by that.
Give me a break, Andrew.
You buy and sell stolen books.
Everybody knows it.
Are you telling me that the police haven't come calling, asking you whether anybody's tried to unload a Rothstein? Yeah, the police came once.
You've now come twice and called twice.
You seem especially interested.
My one chance in life to get my hands on an original why wouldn't I be? 'Kay.
- If the kid comes back - Yeah.
Or anybody else, for that matter I'll call.
So, Morris.
What're you what're you up to these days? What're you into? Excuse me? Well, we're old buddies.
We should catch up more.
Word is that you and Alma Lane have been spending some quality time.
Are you fucking that old battleaxe again? If I were, it'd be none of your fucking business.
Sure would be a curious thing, though.
Rothstein fucked her.
You fucked her.
Forgive me.
I'm just a sucker for coincidence.
Good.
Be seated.
You okay? Fine.
You seem a bit fidgety.
I'm fine.
I'm a fidgety person.
It's not gonna be today, you know.
Like, the prosecution has to make its case first.
- So you got time.
- Okay.
I'm fine.
I'm a fidgety person.
I'm allowed to be a fidgety person.
Good morning, everyone.
Good morning.
Good morning, Ms.
Pace.
Mr.
Finkelstein.
- Ms.
Linklatter.
- Morning.
And I-I just want to remind you all again that this might look and walk and quack like a circus, but it's a courtroom.
It's my courtroom.
Wheels of justice - Get on with it, for fuck's sake.
- The whole ten yards.
Fucking blowhard.
Ms.
Pace? You have the honor.
Thank you, Your Honor.
The People call William Hodges.
Excuse me.
Mr.
Hodges is not on their witness list.
- He's on yours.
- What's going on? - I'm calling my first witness.
- Objection.
All right, approach the bench.
This is not a nice fucking start.
Are you kidding me? He's on the list.
There's no unfair surprise here.
- This is bullshit.
- Bullshit is in play here.
He plans to backdoor jury nullification, and we all know it.
You need to rethink this, young lady.
It's all rethought.
Detective Hodges was in the room.
He was there.
He's a material eyewitness.
- And now he's here.
- I want time to prep him.
You mean coach him? - Fuck you.
- Fuck you.
Fuck both of you.
This is not a goddamn good start.
You got five minutes.
- Your Honor - That's it.
He can take a breath.
He can have a moment.
He can take a dump.
But he's in that chair in five minutes.
You got that? You wanted to see me? Oh, Peter.
Yes, come in.
Is there something wrong? Not at all.
This is one of the very best student papers I've read in quite a long time.
Really? Because it was so confident.
Thank you.
Hang on a sec.
Would you sit? Did you write it? Of course I did.
It's just that You have never written anything like this.
Well, to be honest, I've never really loved the books in your class till this one.
Well, I'm not sure I agree with your conclusions.
You say that Jimmy is a noble American hero, but is that really supported by the concluding book in the trilogy? Jimmy's still a rebel in the end.
Why? Because he throws an ashtray through a TV screen? That's a symbol.
Tell me.
The CBS logo is an eye, and Jimmy's act is a ritual blinding of his inner eye, the one that sees the truth.
Well you really are a Rothstein man.
I'm impressed.
But in your paper, you you don't talk about how he died.
- No.
- Well, I have to wonder why.
I mean, this just happened.
It wouldn't have fit the theme, and just to die like that At least Rothstein's major work was done.
Unless you're one of those people who believe he was still writing, and that he left this trove of treasures.
Well, I'd really love to read those if that's true.
Mm-hmm.
I gotta go to class, um You swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God? - I do.
- Be seated.
Mr.
Hodges.
Ms.
Pace.
You're a retired detective with the Bridgton Police Department? I am.
You were the lead detective tasked with investigating the jobs fair massacre, perpetrated by Brady Hartsfield.
I was.
You retired from the force, having made no arrest on the case, but you had occasion to pursue the matter as a private detective.
I did.
Would it be fair to say that you were consumed with bringing Mr.
Hartsfield down? It would.
Fair to say you wanted Brady Hartsfield dead? I wanted justice, which he got.
When a criminal defendant is executed before he's brought to trial, that coincides with your notion of justice? There were extenuating circumstances here.
Which were? Brady Hartsfield nearly killed her.
The man was evil incarnate.
So if a criminal suspect is evil enough, you support a pre-trial execution? I'm sorry.
Has this witness been called to give testimony or opinion? Mr.
Hodges has a bias in favor of the defendant.
He's in fact a defense witness.
I'm therefore allowed to treat him as hostile and establish that bias.
Well, just get on with it then, please.
Brady Hartsfield, in addition to killing so many, killed someone you had personal feelings for.
Janey Patterson.
Is there a point? My point is that of all the people in this room wanting Mr.
Mercedes to get his just reward, no one would take a backseat to you.
Get on with it, Counsel.
You were there, weren't you, Mr.
Hodges? When Brady Hartsfield was assassinated? - You were sitting right in the room.
- I was.
Can you tell us what you observed? I saw Lou, after giving testimony, leave the witness box.
She approached Mr.
Hartsfield, whispered something in his ear, and produced a weapon, and she shot him.
In the head.
Well, she aimed for his nuts, but she missed.
Is this a joke to you? The joke is that Lou Linklatter is facing trial for performing two seconds of community service.
That's the joke.
After giving testimony, did you observe the defendant rush up to the victim, or did she walk calmly? The latter.
She seemed in control of her mental faculties from your vantage point? She did.
And given your own hatred, your rage towards Mr.
Hartsfield, I'm guessing you'd understand the defendant's fury toward her victim.
You covered that.
In fact, who among us, given the carnage caused by Brady Hartsfield, wouldn't want to blow that monster's head off? Trilogy now.
You've made that point three times.
If you had the chance, would you have killed him? Did you not hear my question, Detective? No, I heard the question.
It's hypothetical.
It's actually not hypothetical, because you had two such occasions to kill Brady Hartsfield, where in fact, you began to kill Brady Hartsfield, once in a hospital room when you pinched his oxygen line, the other in a cell when you grabbed him by the throat and began to strangle him.
In both cases, you stopped yourself, didn't you, Detective? I did.
Why? Don't much remember, truth be told.
That's not "truth be told.
" That's a lie.
You stopped yourself on both occasions because you did not want to sink to Brady Hartsfield's level.
You did not want to be lawless like him.
A mind-reader now.
Jack of all jack-offs.
I don't need to be a mind-reader, because you gave that exact statement to the police.
You even said to be rendered lawless means that Brady Hartsfield wins.
You did not want to give him that satisfaction the very satisfaction that Lou Linklatter gave him.
Your Honor, what is the point of this? Mr.
Hodges is not on trial here.
No, he's not, because he did not commit a homicide.
But he is here to give testimony in support of someone who did.
You're a unique witness in this case, Mr.
Hodges.
You know and care for the defendant.
You harbored a compulsion to get Mr.
Hartsfield, who, as you say, was evil.
You can appreciate the anguish of his victims, many of them with us here today.
You're unequivocally on the "hate Mr.
Mercedes" side of the fence.
But you are also a man of law and order.
You're a man who believes that this system needs to be one of integrity, so I'm going to finish here by asking you the toughest question of all, reminding you that you are under oath.
One hell of a windup.
As much as you understand why Lou Linklatter took the law into her own hands, do you really mean to sit in that chair and advocate on behalf of vigilantism? I'm here to advocate for Lou.
He stabbed her, for God's sake.
So eye for an eye.
That's where you stand? Is it your testimony that people, for the purpose of exacting revenge, should be allowed to take the law into their own hands? Thank you, Your Honor.
Let Lou go! Let Lou go! We love you! Let Lou go! Let Lou go! Over here! Detective Hodges! Why did Brady - Why did Lou kill Brady? - Detective Hodges! Let Lou go! Let Lou go! Let Lou go! Let Lou go! Thanks for all the help.
Sitting there like a fucking zombie.
Why didn't you say something? You could've established Brady was able to keep killing, - even in custody - The judge shut that down.
Slip it in sideways, for fuck's sake.
No, because if I even go near self-defense, I would be put in contempt of court.
- Do you understand that? - All the Cerebellin, medical wonder boy bullshit, the whole thing None of that negates that Lou executed him, and for us to try to deny that we will look like we're okay with murder! What's your plan? I've told you our plan.
Involuntary manslaughter.
It's a fine line one that I can walk.
- I don't fucking think so.
- Okay, stop it, both of you.
I have to be off to see Carl Fenten's dad.
Maybe you can go and get yourself a law degree or something.
- I'll see you back at the office - Fuck off.
Fuck off yourself.
See you back in the office.
Did it go that badly? Not at all.
No new information came in.
He came off sympathetic to Lou, which the jury saw.
He's just not the cleanup hitter that we hoped.
- Right.
- It's all going to come down to Lou's testimony anyway, and yours.
Right.
Holly.
If you don't feel up to it No, I have to be up to it.
I will just ask questions.
And you just give honest answers.
You just just be yourself.
'Kay.
Yeah.
I can't be bothered To miss you anymore It's month 12, day 31, and hour 24 I used to think Shit, shit, shit.
- Is he in trouble? - Not at all.
Then I don't understand.
The crash site was less than a mile from here.
Peter has been known to walk the area.
It's possible he came upon the wreckage.
But he didn't.
He would've told us.
There was money, we think, in the car, possibly connected to the John Rothstein murder.
It's possible some of Rothstein's merchandise, manuscripts, even, were in the wreckage.
And it's possible somebody came upon the crash site, found the money and merchandise, and absconded with it.
You think Peter did this? We're talking to everybody in the vicinity.
How has Peter seemed recently? How has he seemed? Mrs.
Saubers, we're really not trying to be antagonistic.
Okay, you are in my home, asking questions about my son and whether or not he's in possession of stolen property.
What is that if not antagonistic? And what about your husband? Where is he? He's in court.
Court? The trial for the woman who killed Mr.
Mercedes.
My husband was crippled at the jobs massacre.
We noticed, uh, he recently leased some space on Center Street.
Yes.
He used to be a real estate broker before the accident, and he's decided to get back into it.
It's not cheap leasing space right on Center Street.
Did he come into some money recently? An inheritance, maybe? Don Fenten? You a cop? May I have a word, please? My son was a dope.
He was good at driving cars, which is why I think he was chosen to do something way, way over his head.
He didn't kill Rothstein.
How can you know that? My son didn't own a gun.
You check his priors, robbery, yes, but never armed robbery.
It just wasn't in Carl.
The other guy killed Rothstein.
Had to be.
Well, let's turn to the other guy.
You can't conceive who it might be? Somebody dominant.
Somebody alpha.
I don't think he had any idea what he was getting himself into.
It might help if you could visit her before court.
In lockup? Oh, it'd have to be lockup.
They're not gonna let her out to make a burger run.
- If you'd rather not, though - No, I can do it.
Holly I admit I'm a little torn.
I'm duty-bound to protect Lou's constitution any way I can if she becomes unhinged.
But I also worry about your own emotional footing.
I don't know how to be.
Well, as I said, you just be yourself, and I'll just ask the questions No, I don't mean in court.
I mean, right now.
I don't know how to be sitting in a car with you.
You're scared I might try to kiss you or something? No.
Well, yeah.
- N-no.
- Oh, so we're clear, then? No, I'm I I am afraid that you'll kiss me.
I'm terrified of it, but I also want to kiss you.
But what I want is way trumped by fear.
Terror.
You may be the most honest person I've ever met.
See, and that terrifies me because it was sweet, you know, it was nice in a path-to-intimacy kind of way.
That makes me need to pee.
Sorry.
Okay.
- Look.
- Mm-hmm? I'm not going to kiss you tonight.
But I don't want you to fear the future.
I'm just gonna show you what it would be like so you'll be less terrified of it.
How was it? It was really, really good.
I mean, albeit in a short and uneventful way.
Wait, can you put me on the stand still now that you kissed me, though? I can.
'Kay.
I don't know why I asked.
Suspected something how? I don't know.
He just seemed suspicious.
Curious as to my interest in Rothstein, - even though he's known forever - And the Saubers kid hasn't been back to the bookstore? - Not once? - So he says.
I wonder.
Police being at the Saubers house obviously, we're not the only ones sniffing this kid.
I'm almost rooting for the cops at this point.
Excuse me? If they find those books, you know, I won't get rich, but at least I'll get to read them, maybe.
My God.
That's really what it's about with you, isn't it? Getting to read those books.
I have to see what he became.
I have to know.
I'm gonna try again tomorrow with the mother.
Hopefully, the cops won't be there.
Who are you texting? Danielle.
I still don't get it.
Gone.
Whoosh.
Fucking nothing.
Morris, I'm gonna ask you an honest question, and I want an honest answer.
What? I think it's sweet that you miss your twitty little Danielle.
That's your question? No, my question is, when you fuck me, do you think of that twitty little thing? 'Cause that would not be good.
You're being disgusting.
I don't give a shit.
When a man's in me, he better be all in.
You're going to court tomorrow, by the way.
Court? Why? Because I have an idea.
Don't fucking lie to me, Peter! - I'm not fucking lying.
- Bullshit! - Tom! - He's lying to me.
Bullshit.
Peter, there was money in the car, right? Huh? There were probably Rothstein books as well.
I've got anonymous cash donations showing up at this house in the mail.
You are all into fucking John Rothstein.
- The cops are knocking at the door.
- Dad, Dad, Dad, they're teaching Rothstein in school.
Who the fuck isn't reading Rothstein - Bullshit.
He's lying to me.
- Tom.
Peter.
We are honest people, okay? We may not have much, but we have that.
We are honest people.
Peter, just tell us.
Are you in trouble? I'm not in trouble.
I wanna see those books you got from the library.
- I returned them.
- See? He's fucking lying, Marjorie.
Fuck off! What did you say to me? - You say that to me one more time.
- You wanna fight.
- No! Don't you dare! - You say that to me one more fucking time.
Fuck you! The defense essentially planned to use Hodges as kind of a secret weapon, but the district attorney let the air out of their tires.
You could practically see that big man deflate with a big hiss.
Hey! You're on the TV.
Nobody can call you ordinary now.
You fucked your friend Lou, haven't found my killer, talked about on television you are a spectacular failure.
Nothing spectacular about it.
They only put ordinary failures on TV nowadays.
It makes the ads look better.
Well, there's no such thing as bad publicity, bud.
I mean, "I never miss a chance "to have sex or be interviewed on the TV.
" When did you say that? Gore Vidal said that.
Jesus Christ, bud, you never read anybody but me? Not Gore fucking Vidal, I'll tell you that much.
You spoke to me like you knew who I am, who I was Can I tell you a secret? I never spoke to you.
You're speaking to me now.
You are speaking to you now.
Okay.
If you're so smart, tell me this.
Is Brady Satan? Satan? Brady, Satan? There is no Satan.
Oh, my God.
Satan's a human creation.
He's like God or Cheez Whiz, or, you know Billy, I think you're missing the point.
There's only one way out, and that's in.
Hello? Hello? - Hi.
- Hi.
Ooh, it's a little poochy.
Poochy! What a beautiful dog.
Oh, you whoo! He likes me.
My name is Alma Lane and I am so sorry to disturb you, but my cat, Carleton, he's gone missing, and I'm passing out some flyers.
This is my little Carleton - a bit of a wanderer.
- Usually, I'm not concerned, but it's been over a week now.
Have you seen him? I'm sorry, no.
It's just not like him to stay away this long.
Are you all right, dear? I'm fine.
Why are you staring at me? Oh, I don't mean to.
I'm sorry.
Truth be told, I'm a little psychic.
I walked up here worried about my cat.
Now I'm a little worried about you.
You need to be pretty.
And not too twitchy.
I don't find you twitchy in a bad way, but I need you to be comfortable in your own skin in a way that in a way that I can't.
What? Why are you looking at me like that? I'm worried about you.
You seem erratic.
Yeah, well, I'm on trial for my life, and your boss? He didn't exactly carry the day on my behalf.
Well, I mean, he was a little boxed in by the truth.
Oh, yeah? What about you? I'll need to tell the truth as well.
You and I, we're Brady bashers.
I shot him.
And you oh, girl.
You just Your job is to show the jury that Brady-bashing oh.
It's such a good thing.
Brady-bashing is sympathetic and so pretty.
You have a very odd tone, Lou.
I'm a little uneasy.
I'm gonna be sounding real good when I'm out, though.
She's getting worse.
And the way she talks is how Brady would talk.
I mean, not that I ever spoke with Brady, you know.
I did.
You're not wrong.
He's in her head somehow.
What do we do? First of all, whatever we can to get her out.
- After that - Mr.
Hodges.
Yeah? Sorry to intrude.
I just wanted to say a quick thank you.
My name's Morris Bellamy.
I was at the jobs fair that night one of the lucky ones.
Hello.
Hi.
So many of us are so grateful to both of you.
And I'm not sure it gets said quite enough, so I thought I'd say it.
- Thank you.
- Thank you, both of you.
Again, sorry to intrude.
Wait just a second.
You were one of Brady Hartsfield's victims? Well, emotionally.
I escaped physical harm.
Thank God.
Where's your head at on this? I'm sorry? This trial.
Do you want to see Lou Linklatter convicted or set free? Lou Linklatter's a hero in my book.
Did you have an opportunity to speak with her after? I did.
And did she tell you where she procured the 3-D revolver? She told me she made it herself.
Is that easy to do? No.
There's a fair amount of engineering expertise involved.
Premeditation.
Coherent thinking.
Malice aforethought.
That was all part of the mix of what you observed, was it not, Mr.
Montez? - Objection, foundation.
- Lay opinion.
Move it along.
As you observed the defendant shoot Brady Hartsfield, she appeared to be acting calmly, willfully, and with purpose? Appeared to be the case.
And was Brady Hartsfield posing a threat to anybody when Lou Linklatter acted to end his life? No.
She executed him.
Appeared to be the case.
Thank you, Mr.
Montez.
You swore to tell the truth.
I did.
But you have an even higher obligation to tell it, don't you? You're a prosecutor, an officer of the court.
My obligation is the same as any other witness.
As an Ohio prosecutor, do you know and understand Ohio criminal law? Well, that would be the goal.
Before the shooting, would you say Brady Hartsfield seriously provoked my client? Not in court, not on that day.
In the months leading up to the event, when he attacked her, when he almost killed her, almost killed thousands of people, would you say he provoked her? That's fair.
Did his provocation cause my client to suffer great mental or emotional distress, if you know? Cause her to fear for her life? Cause her to lose sleep, weight, hopes I can't argue with any of that.
A person in Ohio can't be convicted of both murder and manslaughter for the same killing.
No.
It's one or the other.
Because not all killings are the same.
Murder is worse than manslaughter.
When you saw my client shoot Mr.
Mercedes, did you think to yourself, "That woman is a murderer"? I'm not sure I was thinking about it in those terms.
Well, you're a trained prosecutor.
You must've had some opinion, some reaction.
- Objection.
- Sustained.
Seeing a man killed is upsetting.
- It is.
- So is testifying.
Upsetting, scary, nerve-racking for everybody, even you.
You you're not enjoying this.
No.
Did you know how having to give testimony would affect her that day? I didn't realize the extent, no.
Do you make room for the possibility, Mr.
Montez, that having been assaulted by Brady Hartsfield, nearly killed by him in the most vicious way, being stabbed in the stomach, and then having to be in a room with him to face him down do you make room for the possibility that it was just all too much for Lou Linklatter? Is it possible? Of course it's possible.
Thank you.
Calm, coherent, deliberate, reflective, with malice aforethought.
You still stand by that testimony? - I do.
- Thank you, Your Honor.
What do you think? I don't know.
It's close.
Could be bad.
It's hard to be objective.
My testimony could be very important.
You like him, don't you? What? Finkelstein.
You like him.
I do.
What do you think of him? He seems good.
I think it went as well as we can hope.
But you want me to plead.
Well, I'm not saying We're gonna win.
I know it.
Is that what he's telling you? 'Cause he's misled you before.
He's a very complicated person.
He really is.
He hurts me, and then he helps me, and then he hurts me.
All I gotta do is know which one is which.
You made contact? Both with him and the woman, Holly Gibney.
Step one.
Mission accomplished.
Excellent.
What about you and the Saubers mother? Contact also established.
Minimal, but progress.
I'll get inside that family.
It's only a matter of time.
I can tell you this.
She's freaked about something, and it wasn't my lost cat.
Where are you now? Doing a little spring cleaning on the chance the police come sniffing my way.
Gotta make sure there's nothing for 'em to find.
Why would they be coming your way? Hopefully, they won't.
But, Morris, we both entered into the mix.
And that composite they released didn't look a whole lot like you, but I'm not taking any chances.
Your bookstore buddy could connect the dots.
True.
I'll call you when I'm done here.
Don't tell me not to live Just sit and putter Life's candy and the sun's a ball of butter Don't bring around a cloud to rain on my parade Don't tell me not to fly, I've simply got to If someone takes a spill, it's me and not you! Who told you you're allowed to rain on my parade? I'll march my band out I'll beat my drum And if I'm fanned out Your turn at bat, sir At least I didn't fake it Hat, sir, I guess I didn't make it But whether I'm the rose of sheer perfection A freckle on the nose of life's complexion The cinder or I'll march My band out I'll beat My drum And if I'm fanned out Your turn at bat, sir At least I didn't fake it, hat, sir I guess I didn't make it Get ready for me, love, 'cause I'm a comer I simply gotta march, my heart's a drummer Nobody, no Nobody Is gonna Rain on my Parade