Without a Trace s05e19 Episode Script
At Rest
Previously on Without a Trace: Hey, it's Emily.
Special Agent Jack Malone.
I'm Emily Reynolds.
I'm Sam's sister.
Is there anything I can help you with? Um, we were just supposed to meet and have lunch.
Sorry about yesterday.
Got caught up with a case.
No, you didn't.
I hope you're happy.
I hope you have people who love you and take care of you.
It can't be me.
Do you understand that? - It can't be me.
- Please.
- No.
- Sam.
Hello? Yeah, this is Samantha Spade.
Where did you say you were? Okay.
Um Uh, can I meet you there in an hour? Okay.
Yeah.
Um, okay.
Yeah, thanks.
Bye.
What's going on? Uh I gotta go so you gotta go.
No coffee, no toast? You know what, um I'm sorry, what? - Brian.
- Brian, yeah.
Just Just go.
Agent Spade? - Yeah.
Detective King? - Tom.
- Tom.
All this belongs to Emily Reynolds? We found her gym ID and a couple receipts with her name on them.
- Did you find a wallet? - No.
- So it could be a robbery gone bad.
- Maybe.
The security guard found this around 11:30.
Figured some lady left her stuff on the car roof and drove off until he found this.
She got Tasered? Okay, this is, what, 50,000 volts? I mean, somebody must have heard her scream, heard something.
The receipt from those boots indicates she was here before closing.
The parking lot would have been pretty empty.
Your card was in her purse.
That's why I called you.
Hope that's okay.
It's fine.
Is this Emily Reynolds part of one of your cases? No.
She's my sister.
Your sister.
I'm sorry.
I had no idea.
You couldn't have known.
Is there anyone else we should notify? We should contact her husband.
Um, Andrew.
He's a lawyer, works at a big firm in the city.
You know which one? No.
Got a mobile number? No, I My sister and I are not really close.
We He's about 40.
I could have someone at the bureau try and find him.
No, no, we can do it.
I'd like to assist on this, if that's okay.
Happy for the help.
If the husband's some lawyer we should set up a trap and trace at his house.
At least with a ransom, we'd know what we're dealing with.
Excuse me.
King.
This is Special Agent Jack Malone.
I'm not at my desk.
Please leave a message.
Jack, it's Samantha.
Uh, I've had a family thing come up and I'm gonna need a couple days.
If you could just have someone cover for me, that'd be great.
And I will give you a call later.
Okay, bye.
Turns out your sister has a nervous neighbor.
Called the police last week to report a guy in front of her house.
Cruiser went by, but the SUV he was driving was gone.
Did we get a license plate? Got a license plate, make and model.
Lady was very nervous.
I hate to ask this, but - I've got an APB in process.
- Thank you.
Neighbor also gave us a cell phone for the husband.
Want to call him? I've never met him before.
Um, sure.
Not exactly the introduction I'd imagined.
- Andrew.
- Samantha.
I'm sorry we're meeting like this.
I really appreciate you helping out.
I know Emily will too.
It's weird.
She just talked about having you to the house.
Uh, you know, maybe one of us should wait for the tech team.
Yeah, probably.
You go in.
I'll stay.
Thank you.
I was at a conference at Yale for three days.
I spoke to her on the phone a couple of times, but To think if I'd been home, called the police earlier I wouldn't beat yourself up about it.
There's not much you could have done.
Have you noticed anyone hanging around the house? Gotten strange calls? Not that I remember.
How has Emily been? She told me she came to see you.
- Yeah.
- How'd she seem to you? Distracted.
She had been like that for a couple of weeks.
Then about six days ago, I realized that something was going on.
- You're early.
Yeah.
I'm making you pudding.
You like it? It's great.
So Steve Fletcher called me from First Union today wondering if I wanted to cover our overdraft.
You took $20,000 out of our account this week.
I don't know what you want me to say.
Well, I want you to tell me what it's for.
No.
- It's a lot of money.
- Yes, it is.
And for the last 10 years, I've taken care of your life.
You haven't had to worry about a thing.
Not the house or making a doctor's appointment or dinner parties for your partners.
Wind-up to your community property speech? I'm not divorcing you, Andrew.
I just I need the money.
And I want you to trust me about the reasons why I need it.
I think I've earned that.
When these cool, they're gonna need to go in the refrigerator.
I'm a lawyer.
Trust only goes so far.
So to be safe, I put a hold on the account.
She didn't write any more checks.
Did she write the checks to cash? Yeah.
One for $5000, the other for 15,000.
That's a lot of money to ignore.
I love my wife.
I want her to be happy.
And I thought Yeah, and she's right.
We've been married a long time.
Well, you, um You cut off her access to your checking account, right? So you must have thought something more than that.
Emily loved self-help programs.
Meditation, colors reorganizing her closet.
There's a thousand paths to enlightenment.
I thought most of it was ridiculous and she knew that.
I thought maybe she met a new guru she was just too embarrassed to tell me about.
And if that wasn't it, maybe I just didn't wanna know.
- You gotta see this.
- What is it? The Savran case? No, it's an APB alert from Fairfield County for an SUV in connection with the abduction of Emily Reynolds.
- The name ring a bell? - Isn't that Samantha's sister? I confirmed it with Fairfield P.
D.
These were the only photos in the SUV but I sent his memory card down to the lab to be printed.
What's his explanation for these photos? Says he likes a pretty girl.
Yeah, what? What's the problem? She's missing.
What did you do to her? I didn't do nothing.
I was following her.
I ran across some family trouble.
I followed him, I lost him in traffic.
- You don't know who the man is? - No.
- What happened to those pictures? - Gave them to the lawyer who hired me.
- The lawyer's name? Client stuff is confidential.
I'm gonna ask you again.
What was the lawyer's name? - In three seconds - Ow.
Ah! I'm gonna lose all my good feeling towards you.
What was his name? Are you gonna let her do this to me? Aah! - Apparently.
- Ow.
Andrew.
Andrew Reynolds.
Ow.
I gave him the photos.
He told me he didn't need me anymore.
Let's get my sister's husband in here.
Did you really think I wouldn't find out what you did? I don't know what's happened since we spoke but I'm concerned about Emily.
Well, apparently, you're not concerned enough to tell me about this.
What happened? She was having an affair and you tried to teach her a lesson? You've got it all wrong.
Emily wasn't having an affair.
I had her followed, but not for personal reasons.
Then why? There was a leak on a big case in my firm.
It was causing some public-relations problems.
The partners agreed to surveillance of the key employees and their families.
I hired the firm that did that work.
All right, then can you tell me who this guy is? Yeah, she introduced me to him.
He came to the house.
I'm so sorry.
Me too.
I really let myself get my hopes up this time.
Oh, honey, you're home.
The deposition got rescheduled.
Oh, I hope you had a big lunch because I haven't even started supper yet.
Um, Dale, this is my husband, Andrew.
Andrew, this is Dale.
Dale and I are old friends from college and, um he was in town on business.
- Nice to meet you.
- Likewise.
We were just talking about an old friend of ours who had gotten sick.
Well, I should probably get going.
I don't wanna hold your dinner up any longer.
So how long are you going to be in town for? Well, I'll be heading back tomorrow.
But you have my card.
Call me anytime.
Well, thanks for stopping by.
You've got a beautiful home here.
Thank you.
I'm sorry I didn't tell you about it.
I signed a confidentiality agreement.
I saw all the pictures.
I didn't think any of them were relevant.
Do you believe her story about this Dale guy? They were in my living room, in front of a wall of windows.
Not exactly a great place to have an affair.
Did you get his last name? No.
Business card.
Where is it? There was a card on the kitchen counter for a while.
Black with silver lettering.
Right, here's what I would suggest: Unless you want us to officially detain you you stay put until we find that business card.
Hey.
What are you doing here? Usually when people say "family thing" they're talking about picking up a relative from a gall-bladder operation.
- Not looking for their sister.
- I'm taking care of this.
With local P.
D? - They have one missing person per year.
- Shh.
- Our team has their plate full.
- Doesn't explain why you didn't tell me.
Because I don't want my private life in the office.
You know what, Samantha, in the personal arena I would have to say that you consistently make the worst choices.
Present company included? Definitely.
Look, personal issues aside, okay, we're talking about your missing sister.
I know that.
You want the truth? I thought there would be a simple explanation.
- She'd be home by this evening.
- Do you still think that way? No.
Then let me help you.
I do not want this to become a three-ring circus.
Look, it's not gonna happen, okay? We'll keep it quiet.
Okay.
Okay, Emily's phone records.
Scan them for anybody by the name of Dale.
- Okay.
- I couldn't find one in Emily's yearbook.
So it seems like her story about going to school with him is bogus.
I know we dig into people's lives for a living but because this is Sam's sister, I don't know it feels different, kind of like we're snooping.
Well, for the record, if anybody ever Tasers me search into anything you can find.
- You can count on it.
Okay, as far as I can tell, Emily didn't deposit the 20,000 into a bank account.
At least not an onshore bank account.
Well, she does spend money on crystals and past-life retreats.
Maybe Dale was selling a better snake oil.
Yeah, well, if she found out he was running a scam maybe he grabbed her to keep her quiet.
Martin.
Hey, I found the card.
A Dale Enty.
- He's got an 859 phone number.
- Yeah, it's Lexington, Kentucky.
Yeah, and there's a website on the card.
It's HelpRandyLive.
Com.
Okay, HelpRandyLive.
Com.
All right, I got it.
What is it? It's a website to save a dying boy.
I tell you, man, if this thing's a con, it's a really nasty one.
Well, I have no idea where she is.
How about why you lied to her husband about being a friend from college? Her husband walked in that day and she started spinning a story.
I just played along.
And the real story is what? I was there because I needed her help for my son, Randy.
He has non-Hodgkin's lymphoma.
Well, how could Emily Reynolds help you with that? Stop wasting my time, Mr.
Enty, and answer my question.
Emily is his mother.
That's some costume.
- Oh, yeah.
He was constantly saving me.
You know, protecting me from dangerous toasters and scary kids on bikes.
My sister had hair like that.
You know, for a sick kid, he seems really, really happy.
He's a great kid.
And I wouldn't ask you to do this except that the bone-marrow transplant is his last chance.
Obviously, my wife and I were long shots to match.
But since I'm his mother? There's about a 25 percent chance you'll be able to help him.
But I'm not sure that it would do Randy any good to You know, to I mean, obviously, he knows that he's adopted.
- But we've got a good family.
- No, of course.
I understand.
I gave up those rights 17 years ago when I put him up for adoption.
If I could give both my legs and my arms Of course.
Of course you would.
You know, I was pretty messed up when I had him.
But if I can finally do something to help Well, let's just cross our fingers and hope that I can.
Yeah, okay.
The day her husband saw us, she told me she wasn't a match.
And you didn't try to shake her down? I have insurance.
I don't need anyone's money.
What about the real father? What do you know about him? Well, he was listed on the birth certificate as unknown.
Emily said that she'd try to contact him.
Did she? I don't know.
She said it was tricky.
Haven't heard from her since.
Could you excuse me? You okay? Not really.
You had no idea that your sister had a baby? If he's telling the truth, no, I had no idea.
Emily did run away when she was 16.
Um, took a couple changes of clothes and 80 bucks out of our mom's wallet.
She just took off.
I kept waiting for her to come home.
And about a year later, she did.
And she wouldn't talk about where she'd been.
- Two of you never talked about it? - No, she never told me anything.
She came to see me When was it? Thursday.
- Thursday.
I think that she wanted to tell me what was going on and I just blew her off.
And now I'm thinking that maybe she knew the biological father of Randy was violent and she may have wanted me to go with her.
Did she ask you? I didn't really give her a chance to ask me anything.
Why would the biological father take your sister if all she wanted was a bone-marrow match? I don't know.
You know, it's possible that you met him.
I mean, she had boyfriends, right? Emily had a lot of boyfriends.
A lot.
What about your mother? Maybe she remembers meeting him.
No.
No, I mean, I doubt it.
She was holding down two jobs, she had a busy social life.
She was kind of distracted most of the time.
What did she say when you told her that Emily was missing? I haven't told her.
- Why not? - I didn't wanna worry her until we had something solid.
- Right.
Hey, Viv, thanks for helping out.
I think we got something.
Emily bought a ticket to Kenosha three days ago.
That's the same day that Andrew went to that conference at Yale, right? Might need to take a trip to Kenosha.
- Talk to your mother.
- I haven't talked to Mom in I don't know how long.
I don't think she would wanna see me or talk to me, really.
Let's see.
We'll go together.
- Okay.
All right.
Birth certificate the adoptive father has checks out.
Hospital confirms Emily Spade gave birth to a boy.
But the biological father is not listed on any of their paperwork.
Did we notify the P.
D.
In the town where the son lives? We have someone sitting on his house, just in case.
All right, Emily's ATM card was used at a gas station on I-80 outside of Toledo, Ohio.
- Is this Emily? - It's impossible to tell.
If that's her, that's great news.
At least she's not stuffed in a trunk.
- He must need her alive.
- Look at this.
License plate, Wisconsin.
What do you think? Think we can get a registration off of this partial? Well, I'll put out an APB.
You know, if he was forcing her to take him to his son they should have gone south on I-75 to Lexington.
Where's I-80 go? I think Let's see.
Well, yeah, you can follow it to 94 and from there to Wisconsin.
If she went to Kenosha to talk to him why didn't he take her while she was there? Maybe he missed his chance.
Jack and Samantha should be at her mom's by now.
- I'm gonna send this stuff to them.
- Okay.
Mom.
Mom, please.
This is a picture of the man that we think took Emily.
Have you see him before? Do you recognize him? I don't recognize him.
Okay, well, he's unshaven here.
So maybe if you tried to picture him clean-shaven, it would help you.
I have already told you, I didn't even know Emily was pregnant.
So how am I supposed to know about the father? It's just I can't I don't understand how you can have a teenage daughter who's pregnant and you don't notice.
Well, she ran away from home.
And I was worried sick about her the whole time.
Uh Where are you? Just outside Sam's house.
Just thought I'd step outside and give her and her mother some space.
Her relationship with her mother makes mine with my father look like Armistice Day.
- Heh.
Sure that's not revisionist history? Yeah, maybe.
- What's up? - Well, I've been looking at local papers and police logs.
It says here that Patricia Spade and her daughters are on a witness list in the disappearance of a man by the name of Joe Henry.
Turns out that he went missing two and a half months before Emily ran away.
Okay, what about Emily's recent trip out here? Why did she come? She said that Andrew had to go away on business and she thought we should use that time and catch up.
Okay, did she go anywhere, did she meet anyone? I don't know.
She came, we had dinner, we talked, she left.
Damn it, Mom! Why are you so angry? I'm angry because Emily came here looking for the father of her child.
She was under your roof again.
And again, you chose to stick your head in the sand and not notice anything.
Well, you didn't know she was pregnant either.
I was the child.
You're supposed to be the mother.
She had a phone call.
Hello.
Emily? Yes, she's here.
Hold on.
I'm sorry.
She must have stepped out.
She lives in Connecticut.
Why? Hello? Hello? He hung up.
Mom, you told him where I live? - Well, I'm sorry.
I did - You know, I should head to the airport.
And that's it.
She left.
Okay, did he say his name? No.
Can I check your phone records so I can find out where the call came from? Of course.
- Hey.
- Hey.
Hey, while you're running that down I'd like to ask your mom a few questions.
What about? Joe Henry.
Wow, that's a name I haven't heard in a long time.
Do you have any idea what happened to him? No, I never did.
Mom, would you excuse Jack and I? Can I talk to you for a minute? Sure.
What does Joe Henry have to do with anything? He disappeared at right about the same time.
Well, I know.
I mean, the police interviewed my whole family, but that's not relevant.
Maybe it is, maybe it isn't.
Well, we have a photo of the guy who probably took Emily.
He's 35.
I mean, Joe Henry would be probably 60 by now, so You should follow up on that phone call.
I'm gonna talk to your mom.
I've got your mom's records.
The address for that phone number is And the name on the account is Jeff Henry.
- Are you sure? - Yeah.
Sam, he's the guy at the gas station.
Jeff Henry.
B and E at 10, arson at 12, armed robbery at 16.
Looks like we have a criminal prodigy on our hands.
When your mother was going out with Joe Henry, was the son around much? No, but it wouldn't take a lot of face time for him to get Emily pregnant.
All right, that gas station's He could be hitting Kenosha in less than two hours.
Doesn't leave us a lot of time.
What if we split up and I go to his house? I'll drop you at the police station, you could talk to the locals.
- Sounds good.
- You were right.
Joe Henry had something to do with it.
Just not what we thought.
I hate to gloat.
Yes, I always think of you as someone who hates to be right.
Really? FBI.
Where's Jeff Henry? Beats the crap out of me.
- Put your hands where I can see them.
- Whoa, hey! Take it easy.
Yeah, I recognize her.
She came to talk to Jeff.
- When? - Just a couple days ago.
This is the 5000 for the blood test.
Like we agreed.
And if you're a match, there'll be more.
- How much more? - Depends on whether you're a match.
I want double No, triple the five.
Well, that might be possible.
You must think I'm an idiot, Miss Reynolds.
What do you mean? I spoke to a buddy of mine after you called.
It's illegal to buy bone marrow.
It's like a kidney.
- They put you in jail for that.
- Your friend is wrong.
- You're a cop, aren't you? - No.
No.
- Like I said, I work for a foundation.
- Trying to set me up, plant my DNA.
Maybe that VJ store where the clerk got shot.
Cops already tried to lay that on me.
I'm not trying anything like that.
Look, if you don't wanna do this, I Okay.
Fine.
If you call the number that I gave you for the follow-up test and I'll call you next week.
After she left, Jeff followed her back to some house in town.
Then he came back more pissed off.
Do you know why? I'm not sure.
Okay, after he followed her did you hear him mention the name Spade? - Like your name? - Exactly.
There was a piece of mail that Jeff brought back with him.
- Could you get it for me? - Yeah.
What did Jeff do? Thank you for your help.
Please.
No.
Please, don't.
He was hurting me and he wouldn't stop.
You lying bitch.
He was a good man, a good father.
He took us camping, fishing.
I'm not saying that he wasn't a good man.
I'm just saying that with me, he wasn't.
Everything went to hell when he was gone.
Jeff Henry, FBI.
Drop your weapon.
I'll shoot her.
I will! - Nobody needs to shoot anybody.
- This is none of your business.
Out! I can't do that.
You don't wanna do this.
- She's telling the truth about your dad.
- It's not.
How did I know I'd find you here? I know what happened in this place.
It's exactly what she told you.
I'm so sorry.
- I was trying to help my son.
- It's okay.
- We're gonna be okay, aren't we? - No.
No.
Oh, God! Oh, my God.
Oh, Sam.
It's all right.
It's all right.
- Look at me.
Emily.
- Sam, he was gonna kill me.
He's dead.
He's dead.
He can't hurt you anymore, okay? Emily? Emily, listen to me.
Emily, listen to me.
I want you to look at me and focus.
The police are gonna be here any minute.
We've gotta get our stories straight, all right? Are you with me? Okay.
- You all right? - Yeah.
He was gonna kill her, I had to shoot him.
What did Jeff Henry want? Well, she was going to pay him off to get tested for Randy.
I guess the deal went bad.
And why out here? I don't know.
We'll take your sister to Kenosha Presbyterian.
Ride with us? - Sure.
- No, we're gonna follow.
Come with me.
Why you been lying to me? I'm not lying.
You've been very careful.
Just laying out the facts with no complicating truths to get in the way.
And you let me spin my little theories.
Just answer this question: Why couldn't Jeff be the father of that baby? Are you really, um, gonna ask me to do this right now? My sister almost got killed.
- I wanna go be with her.
Is that okay? - No, we're gonna do it right now.
You know the answer.
He couldn't be the father of the baby because he was in juvie when Randy was conceived.
I didn't know that.
You didn't know that.
Joe Henry is the father.
And he's dead.
And he's out here somewhere.
I have no idea what you're talking about.
I don Your sister went to Jeff to get the bone marrow because she couldn't go to the father.
You know why? Because he's dead and she killed him.
If you don't tell me the truth, I am gonna start handing out shovels and getting people to dig until I can prove that your sister killed him.
That won't be necessary.
I did it.
- You don't have to cover for your sister - I killed him.
He was hurting Emily and I just couldn't let it go on.
No, please! No.
No.
No.
Please stop.
Just please stop.
Stop, Sam! Stop! All Emily did was help me bury him.
She didn't do anything other than that.
And we never talked about it again.
We never talked about much of anything again, so Where's the body? About 40 yards that way.
What about the son? I killed him because I had to, not because I wanted to.
I'm gonna tell the bureau.
I'm gonna come clean and I just Is it all right if I? Will you? I wanna go see Emily first, if that's all right.
Can I? Sure, go ahead.
Jeff's dead.
We're the only ones that know what happened.
- Nobody else needs to know the truth.
- Yes, they do.
Then I'll tell them that I did it.
That I killed him.
He raped me, Sam.
Everybody would understand why I did it.
We can't do that, Em.
Why not? Because I already told Jack.
Why would you do that? Because it's time.
It's time to stop running.
It's time to stop pretending that it didn't happen, because it did.
All of it and I'm The inspector from OPR should be here any minute.
I'm okay to wait.
- So when did you get back into town? - Yesterday.
And how was your trip back? A little bumpy over the lakes.
But not bad.
Sorry we're late.
- Didn't know you were going to be here.
- Oh, I just thought I should be.
Hi.
- Agent Spade.
- Agent Newman.
This is use of force hearing for case 66F-NY-273894.
Present are Special Agents Alexander Olczyk Jack Malone, Samantha Spade and representing OPR, Jonathan Newman.
Can you tell me the circumstances surrounding the shooting? We just finished the incident report last night.
Um, I would like to read a summary into the record first, if that's okay? Sure.
Great.
"Though the full nature of Jeff Henry's intent cannot be known by his own statements, he blamed Emily Spade for his father's disappearance an outgrowth of his misunderstanding of his father's affair with Emily's mother during the same time.
As a result, Henry abducted Emily Reynolds transporting her to a property formerly owned by his family.
There, Special Agent Spade confronted him and when he would not surrender, shot him once to prevent injury to others specifically Emily Reynolds, who he was holding at gunpoint.
And this shooting, though unavoidable, proved fatal.
" Um, the timeline of the investigation is laid out in the report and incorporated by reference.
Agent Spade.
You didn't sign it.
Oh, sorry.
That's my fault.
There were some typos and I had to get it reprinted.
Oh.
Thanks.
We'll have the administrative part of this taken care of by the end of business.
Thank you, Agent Newman.
- Take care.
Thanks.
Sorry to blind-side you like that.
You made it impossible for me to tell the truth without getting you in trouble.
I know.
So did you get the bone-marrow test? I'm not a match, but they did an HLA test.
It looks good for my mom.
Great.
I was gonna tell the truth.
- I'm kind of tired of being stuck in this.
- But you're not stuck anymore.
You did tell the truth.
To me.
What do I do? I just forget about it? No.
You learn how to forgive yourself.
Forgive yourself so if you screw up, it's for something you do now.
Not for something that happened decades ago that you had no control over.
Is that supposed to be wise? No, not really.
I'm just not ready to see you leave yet.
I'm tired, Jack.
I know you are, honey.
Why don't you take a couple days off? I will.
Special Agent Jack Malone.
I'm Emily Reynolds.
I'm Sam's sister.
Is there anything I can help you with? Um, we were just supposed to meet and have lunch.
Sorry about yesterday.
Got caught up with a case.
No, you didn't.
I hope you're happy.
I hope you have people who love you and take care of you.
It can't be me.
Do you understand that? - It can't be me.
- Please.
- No.
- Sam.
Hello? Yeah, this is Samantha Spade.
Where did you say you were? Okay.
Um Uh, can I meet you there in an hour? Okay.
Yeah.
Um, okay.
Yeah, thanks.
Bye.
What's going on? Uh I gotta go so you gotta go.
No coffee, no toast? You know what, um I'm sorry, what? - Brian.
- Brian, yeah.
Just Just go.
Agent Spade? - Yeah.
Detective King? - Tom.
- Tom.
All this belongs to Emily Reynolds? We found her gym ID and a couple receipts with her name on them.
- Did you find a wallet? - No.
- So it could be a robbery gone bad.
- Maybe.
The security guard found this around 11:30.
Figured some lady left her stuff on the car roof and drove off until he found this.
She got Tasered? Okay, this is, what, 50,000 volts? I mean, somebody must have heard her scream, heard something.
The receipt from those boots indicates she was here before closing.
The parking lot would have been pretty empty.
Your card was in her purse.
That's why I called you.
Hope that's okay.
It's fine.
Is this Emily Reynolds part of one of your cases? No.
She's my sister.
Your sister.
I'm sorry.
I had no idea.
You couldn't have known.
Is there anyone else we should notify? We should contact her husband.
Um, Andrew.
He's a lawyer, works at a big firm in the city.
You know which one? No.
Got a mobile number? No, I My sister and I are not really close.
We He's about 40.
I could have someone at the bureau try and find him.
No, no, we can do it.
I'd like to assist on this, if that's okay.
Happy for the help.
If the husband's some lawyer we should set up a trap and trace at his house.
At least with a ransom, we'd know what we're dealing with.
Excuse me.
King.
This is Special Agent Jack Malone.
I'm not at my desk.
Please leave a message.
Jack, it's Samantha.
Uh, I've had a family thing come up and I'm gonna need a couple days.
If you could just have someone cover for me, that'd be great.
And I will give you a call later.
Okay, bye.
Turns out your sister has a nervous neighbor.
Called the police last week to report a guy in front of her house.
Cruiser went by, but the SUV he was driving was gone.
Did we get a license plate? Got a license plate, make and model.
Lady was very nervous.
I hate to ask this, but - I've got an APB in process.
- Thank you.
Neighbor also gave us a cell phone for the husband.
Want to call him? I've never met him before.
Um, sure.
Not exactly the introduction I'd imagined.
- Andrew.
- Samantha.
I'm sorry we're meeting like this.
I really appreciate you helping out.
I know Emily will too.
It's weird.
She just talked about having you to the house.
Uh, you know, maybe one of us should wait for the tech team.
Yeah, probably.
You go in.
I'll stay.
Thank you.
I was at a conference at Yale for three days.
I spoke to her on the phone a couple of times, but To think if I'd been home, called the police earlier I wouldn't beat yourself up about it.
There's not much you could have done.
Have you noticed anyone hanging around the house? Gotten strange calls? Not that I remember.
How has Emily been? She told me she came to see you.
- Yeah.
- How'd she seem to you? Distracted.
She had been like that for a couple of weeks.
Then about six days ago, I realized that something was going on.
- You're early.
Yeah.
I'm making you pudding.
You like it? It's great.
So Steve Fletcher called me from First Union today wondering if I wanted to cover our overdraft.
You took $20,000 out of our account this week.
I don't know what you want me to say.
Well, I want you to tell me what it's for.
No.
- It's a lot of money.
- Yes, it is.
And for the last 10 years, I've taken care of your life.
You haven't had to worry about a thing.
Not the house or making a doctor's appointment or dinner parties for your partners.
Wind-up to your community property speech? I'm not divorcing you, Andrew.
I just I need the money.
And I want you to trust me about the reasons why I need it.
I think I've earned that.
When these cool, they're gonna need to go in the refrigerator.
I'm a lawyer.
Trust only goes so far.
So to be safe, I put a hold on the account.
She didn't write any more checks.
Did she write the checks to cash? Yeah.
One for $5000, the other for 15,000.
That's a lot of money to ignore.
I love my wife.
I want her to be happy.
And I thought Yeah, and she's right.
We've been married a long time.
Well, you, um You cut off her access to your checking account, right? So you must have thought something more than that.
Emily loved self-help programs.
Meditation, colors reorganizing her closet.
There's a thousand paths to enlightenment.
I thought most of it was ridiculous and she knew that.
I thought maybe she met a new guru she was just too embarrassed to tell me about.
And if that wasn't it, maybe I just didn't wanna know.
- You gotta see this.
- What is it? The Savran case? No, it's an APB alert from Fairfield County for an SUV in connection with the abduction of Emily Reynolds.
- The name ring a bell? - Isn't that Samantha's sister? I confirmed it with Fairfield P.
D.
These were the only photos in the SUV but I sent his memory card down to the lab to be printed.
What's his explanation for these photos? Says he likes a pretty girl.
Yeah, what? What's the problem? She's missing.
What did you do to her? I didn't do nothing.
I was following her.
I ran across some family trouble.
I followed him, I lost him in traffic.
- You don't know who the man is? - No.
- What happened to those pictures? - Gave them to the lawyer who hired me.
- The lawyer's name? Client stuff is confidential.
I'm gonna ask you again.
What was the lawyer's name? - In three seconds - Ow.
Ah! I'm gonna lose all my good feeling towards you.
What was his name? Are you gonna let her do this to me? Aah! - Apparently.
- Ow.
Andrew.
Andrew Reynolds.
Ow.
I gave him the photos.
He told me he didn't need me anymore.
Let's get my sister's husband in here.
Did you really think I wouldn't find out what you did? I don't know what's happened since we spoke but I'm concerned about Emily.
Well, apparently, you're not concerned enough to tell me about this.
What happened? She was having an affair and you tried to teach her a lesson? You've got it all wrong.
Emily wasn't having an affair.
I had her followed, but not for personal reasons.
Then why? There was a leak on a big case in my firm.
It was causing some public-relations problems.
The partners agreed to surveillance of the key employees and their families.
I hired the firm that did that work.
All right, then can you tell me who this guy is? Yeah, she introduced me to him.
He came to the house.
I'm so sorry.
Me too.
I really let myself get my hopes up this time.
Oh, honey, you're home.
The deposition got rescheduled.
Oh, I hope you had a big lunch because I haven't even started supper yet.
Um, Dale, this is my husband, Andrew.
Andrew, this is Dale.
Dale and I are old friends from college and, um he was in town on business.
- Nice to meet you.
- Likewise.
We were just talking about an old friend of ours who had gotten sick.
Well, I should probably get going.
I don't wanna hold your dinner up any longer.
So how long are you going to be in town for? Well, I'll be heading back tomorrow.
But you have my card.
Call me anytime.
Well, thanks for stopping by.
You've got a beautiful home here.
Thank you.
I'm sorry I didn't tell you about it.
I signed a confidentiality agreement.
I saw all the pictures.
I didn't think any of them were relevant.
Do you believe her story about this Dale guy? They were in my living room, in front of a wall of windows.
Not exactly a great place to have an affair.
Did you get his last name? No.
Business card.
Where is it? There was a card on the kitchen counter for a while.
Black with silver lettering.
Right, here's what I would suggest: Unless you want us to officially detain you you stay put until we find that business card.
Hey.
What are you doing here? Usually when people say "family thing" they're talking about picking up a relative from a gall-bladder operation.
- Not looking for their sister.
- I'm taking care of this.
With local P.
D? - They have one missing person per year.
- Shh.
- Our team has their plate full.
- Doesn't explain why you didn't tell me.
Because I don't want my private life in the office.
You know what, Samantha, in the personal arena I would have to say that you consistently make the worst choices.
Present company included? Definitely.
Look, personal issues aside, okay, we're talking about your missing sister.
I know that.
You want the truth? I thought there would be a simple explanation.
- She'd be home by this evening.
- Do you still think that way? No.
Then let me help you.
I do not want this to become a three-ring circus.
Look, it's not gonna happen, okay? We'll keep it quiet.
Okay.
Okay, Emily's phone records.
Scan them for anybody by the name of Dale.
- Okay.
- I couldn't find one in Emily's yearbook.
So it seems like her story about going to school with him is bogus.
I know we dig into people's lives for a living but because this is Sam's sister, I don't know it feels different, kind of like we're snooping.
Well, for the record, if anybody ever Tasers me search into anything you can find.
- You can count on it.
Okay, as far as I can tell, Emily didn't deposit the 20,000 into a bank account.
At least not an onshore bank account.
Well, she does spend money on crystals and past-life retreats.
Maybe Dale was selling a better snake oil.
Yeah, well, if she found out he was running a scam maybe he grabbed her to keep her quiet.
Martin.
Hey, I found the card.
A Dale Enty.
- He's got an 859 phone number.
- Yeah, it's Lexington, Kentucky.
Yeah, and there's a website on the card.
It's HelpRandyLive.
Com.
Okay, HelpRandyLive.
Com.
All right, I got it.
What is it? It's a website to save a dying boy.
I tell you, man, if this thing's a con, it's a really nasty one.
Well, I have no idea where she is.
How about why you lied to her husband about being a friend from college? Her husband walked in that day and she started spinning a story.
I just played along.
And the real story is what? I was there because I needed her help for my son, Randy.
He has non-Hodgkin's lymphoma.
Well, how could Emily Reynolds help you with that? Stop wasting my time, Mr.
Enty, and answer my question.
Emily is his mother.
That's some costume.
- Oh, yeah.
He was constantly saving me.
You know, protecting me from dangerous toasters and scary kids on bikes.
My sister had hair like that.
You know, for a sick kid, he seems really, really happy.
He's a great kid.
And I wouldn't ask you to do this except that the bone-marrow transplant is his last chance.
Obviously, my wife and I were long shots to match.
But since I'm his mother? There's about a 25 percent chance you'll be able to help him.
But I'm not sure that it would do Randy any good to You know, to I mean, obviously, he knows that he's adopted.
- But we've got a good family.
- No, of course.
I understand.
I gave up those rights 17 years ago when I put him up for adoption.
If I could give both my legs and my arms Of course.
Of course you would.
You know, I was pretty messed up when I had him.
But if I can finally do something to help Well, let's just cross our fingers and hope that I can.
Yeah, okay.
The day her husband saw us, she told me she wasn't a match.
And you didn't try to shake her down? I have insurance.
I don't need anyone's money.
What about the real father? What do you know about him? Well, he was listed on the birth certificate as unknown.
Emily said that she'd try to contact him.
Did she? I don't know.
She said it was tricky.
Haven't heard from her since.
Could you excuse me? You okay? Not really.
You had no idea that your sister had a baby? If he's telling the truth, no, I had no idea.
Emily did run away when she was 16.
Um, took a couple changes of clothes and 80 bucks out of our mom's wallet.
She just took off.
I kept waiting for her to come home.
And about a year later, she did.
And she wouldn't talk about where she'd been.
- Two of you never talked about it? - No, she never told me anything.
She came to see me When was it? Thursday.
- Thursday.
I think that she wanted to tell me what was going on and I just blew her off.
And now I'm thinking that maybe she knew the biological father of Randy was violent and she may have wanted me to go with her.
Did she ask you? I didn't really give her a chance to ask me anything.
Why would the biological father take your sister if all she wanted was a bone-marrow match? I don't know.
You know, it's possible that you met him.
I mean, she had boyfriends, right? Emily had a lot of boyfriends.
A lot.
What about your mother? Maybe she remembers meeting him.
No.
No, I mean, I doubt it.
She was holding down two jobs, she had a busy social life.
She was kind of distracted most of the time.
What did she say when you told her that Emily was missing? I haven't told her.
- Why not? - I didn't wanna worry her until we had something solid.
- Right.
Hey, Viv, thanks for helping out.
I think we got something.
Emily bought a ticket to Kenosha three days ago.
That's the same day that Andrew went to that conference at Yale, right? Might need to take a trip to Kenosha.
- Talk to your mother.
- I haven't talked to Mom in I don't know how long.
I don't think she would wanna see me or talk to me, really.
Let's see.
We'll go together.
- Okay.
All right.
Birth certificate the adoptive father has checks out.
Hospital confirms Emily Spade gave birth to a boy.
But the biological father is not listed on any of their paperwork.
Did we notify the P.
D.
In the town where the son lives? We have someone sitting on his house, just in case.
All right, Emily's ATM card was used at a gas station on I-80 outside of Toledo, Ohio.
- Is this Emily? - It's impossible to tell.
If that's her, that's great news.
At least she's not stuffed in a trunk.
- He must need her alive.
- Look at this.
License plate, Wisconsin.
What do you think? Think we can get a registration off of this partial? Well, I'll put out an APB.
You know, if he was forcing her to take him to his son they should have gone south on I-75 to Lexington.
Where's I-80 go? I think Let's see.
Well, yeah, you can follow it to 94 and from there to Wisconsin.
If she went to Kenosha to talk to him why didn't he take her while she was there? Maybe he missed his chance.
Jack and Samantha should be at her mom's by now.
- I'm gonna send this stuff to them.
- Okay.
Mom.
Mom, please.
This is a picture of the man that we think took Emily.
Have you see him before? Do you recognize him? I don't recognize him.
Okay, well, he's unshaven here.
So maybe if you tried to picture him clean-shaven, it would help you.
I have already told you, I didn't even know Emily was pregnant.
So how am I supposed to know about the father? It's just I can't I don't understand how you can have a teenage daughter who's pregnant and you don't notice.
Well, she ran away from home.
And I was worried sick about her the whole time.
Uh Where are you? Just outside Sam's house.
Just thought I'd step outside and give her and her mother some space.
Her relationship with her mother makes mine with my father look like Armistice Day.
- Heh.
Sure that's not revisionist history? Yeah, maybe.
- What's up? - Well, I've been looking at local papers and police logs.
It says here that Patricia Spade and her daughters are on a witness list in the disappearance of a man by the name of Joe Henry.
Turns out that he went missing two and a half months before Emily ran away.
Okay, what about Emily's recent trip out here? Why did she come? She said that Andrew had to go away on business and she thought we should use that time and catch up.
Okay, did she go anywhere, did she meet anyone? I don't know.
She came, we had dinner, we talked, she left.
Damn it, Mom! Why are you so angry? I'm angry because Emily came here looking for the father of her child.
She was under your roof again.
And again, you chose to stick your head in the sand and not notice anything.
Well, you didn't know she was pregnant either.
I was the child.
You're supposed to be the mother.
She had a phone call.
Hello.
Emily? Yes, she's here.
Hold on.
I'm sorry.
She must have stepped out.
She lives in Connecticut.
Why? Hello? Hello? He hung up.
Mom, you told him where I live? - Well, I'm sorry.
I did - You know, I should head to the airport.
And that's it.
She left.
Okay, did he say his name? No.
Can I check your phone records so I can find out where the call came from? Of course.
- Hey.
- Hey.
Hey, while you're running that down I'd like to ask your mom a few questions.
What about? Joe Henry.
Wow, that's a name I haven't heard in a long time.
Do you have any idea what happened to him? No, I never did.
Mom, would you excuse Jack and I? Can I talk to you for a minute? Sure.
What does Joe Henry have to do with anything? He disappeared at right about the same time.
Well, I know.
I mean, the police interviewed my whole family, but that's not relevant.
Maybe it is, maybe it isn't.
Well, we have a photo of the guy who probably took Emily.
He's 35.
I mean, Joe Henry would be probably 60 by now, so You should follow up on that phone call.
I'm gonna talk to your mom.
I've got your mom's records.
The address for that phone number is And the name on the account is Jeff Henry.
- Are you sure? - Yeah.
Sam, he's the guy at the gas station.
Jeff Henry.
B and E at 10, arson at 12, armed robbery at 16.
Looks like we have a criminal prodigy on our hands.
When your mother was going out with Joe Henry, was the son around much? No, but it wouldn't take a lot of face time for him to get Emily pregnant.
All right, that gas station's He could be hitting Kenosha in less than two hours.
Doesn't leave us a lot of time.
What if we split up and I go to his house? I'll drop you at the police station, you could talk to the locals.
- Sounds good.
- You were right.
Joe Henry had something to do with it.
Just not what we thought.
I hate to gloat.
Yes, I always think of you as someone who hates to be right.
Really? FBI.
Where's Jeff Henry? Beats the crap out of me.
- Put your hands where I can see them.
- Whoa, hey! Take it easy.
Yeah, I recognize her.
She came to talk to Jeff.
- When? - Just a couple days ago.
This is the 5000 for the blood test.
Like we agreed.
And if you're a match, there'll be more.
- How much more? - Depends on whether you're a match.
I want double No, triple the five.
Well, that might be possible.
You must think I'm an idiot, Miss Reynolds.
What do you mean? I spoke to a buddy of mine after you called.
It's illegal to buy bone marrow.
It's like a kidney.
- They put you in jail for that.
- Your friend is wrong.
- You're a cop, aren't you? - No.
No.
- Like I said, I work for a foundation.
- Trying to set me up, plant my DNA.
Maybe that VJ store where the clerk got shot.
Cops already tried to lay that on me.
I'm not trying anything like that.
Look, if you don't wanna do this, I Okay.
Fine.
If you call the number that I gave you for the follow-up test and I'll call you next week.
After she left, Jeff followed her back to some house in town.
Then he came back more pissed off.
Do you know why? I'm not sure.
Okay, after he followed her did you hear him mention the name Spade? - Like your name? - Exactly.
There was a piece of mail that Jeff brought back with him.
- Could you get it for me? - Yeah.
What did Jeff do? Thank you for your help.
Please.
No.
Please, don't.
He was hurting me and he wouldn't stop.
You lying bitch.
He was a good man, a good father.
He took us camping, fishing.
I'm not saying that he wasn't a good man.
I'm just saying that with me, he wasn't.
Everything went to hell when he was gone.
Jeff Henry, FBI.
Drop your weapon.
I'll shoot her.
I will! - Nobody needs to shoot anybody.
- This is none of your business.
Out! I can't do that.
You don't wanna do this.
- She's telling the truth about your dad.
- It's not.
How did I know I'd find you here? I know what happened in this place.
It's exactly what she told you.
I'm so sorry.
- I was trying to help my son.
- It's okay.
- We're gonna be okay, aren't we? - No.
No.
Oh, God! Oh, my God.
Oh, Sam.
It's all right.
It's all right.
- Look at me.
Emily.
- Sam, he was gonna kill me.
He's dead.
He's dead.
He can't hurt you anymore, okay? Emily? Emily, listen to me.
Emily, listen to me.
I want you to look at me and focus.
The police are gonna be here any minute.
We've gotta get our stories straight, all right? Are you with me? Okay.
- You all right? - Yeah.
He was gonna kill her, I had to shoot him.
What did Jeff Henry want? Well, she was going to pay him off to get tested for Randy.
I guess the deal went bad.
And why out here? I don't know.
We'll take your sister to Kenosha Presbyterian.
Ride with us? - Sure.
- No, we're gonna follow.
Come with me.
Why you been lying to me? I'm not lying.
You've been very careful.
Just laying out the facts with no complicating truths to get in the way.
And you let me spin my little theories.
Just answer this question: Why couldn't Jeff be the father of that baby? Are you really, um, gonna ask me to do this right now? My sister almost got killed.
- I wanna go be with her.
Is that okay? - No, we're gonna do it right now.
You know the answer.
He couldn't be the father of the baby because he was in juvie when Randy was conceived.
I didn't know that.
You didn't know that.
Joe Henry is the father.
And he's dead.
And he's out here somewhere.
I have no idea what you're talking about.
I don Your sister went to Jeff to get the bone marrow because she couldn't go to the father.
You know why? Because he's dead and she killed him.
If you don't tell me the truth, I am gonna start handing out shovels and getting people to dig until I can prove that your sister killed him.
That won't be necessary.
I did it.
- You don't have to cover for your sister - I killed him.
He was hurting Emily and I just couldn't let it go on.
No, please! No.
No.
No.
Please stop.
Just please stop.
Stop, Sam! Stop! All Emily did was help me bury him.
She didn't do anything other than that.
And we never talked about it again.
We never talked about much of anything again, so Where's the body? About 40 yards that way.
What about the son? I killed him because I had to, not because I wanted to.
I'm gonna tell the bureau.
I'm gonna come clean and I just Is it all right if I? Will you? I wanna go see Emily first, if that's all right.
Can I? Sure, go ahead.
Jeff's dead.
We're the only ones that know what happened.
- Nobody else needs to know the truth.
- Yes, they do.
Then I'll tell them that I did it.
That I killed him.
He raped me, Sam.
Everybody would understand why I did it.
We can't do that, Em.
Why not? Because I already told Jack.
Why would you do that? Because it's time.
It's time to stop running.
It's time to stop pretending that it didn't happen, because it did.
All of it and I'm The inspector from OPR should be here any minute.
I'm okay to wait.
- So when did you get back into town? - Yesterday.
And how was your trip back? A little bumpy over the lakes.
But not bad.
Sorry we're late.
- Didn't know you were going to be here.
- Oh, I just thought I should be.
Hi.
- Agent Spade.
- Agent Newman.
This is use of force hearing for case 66F-NY-273894.
Present are Special Agents Alexander Olczyk Jack Malone, Samantha Spade and representing OPR, Jonathan Newman.
Can you tell me the circumstances surrounding the shooting? We just finished the incident report last night.
Um, I would like to read a summary into the record first, if that's okay? Sure.
Great.
"Though the full nature of Jeff Henry's intent cannot be known by his own statements, he blamed Emily Spade for his father's disappearance an outgrowth of his misunderstanding of his father's affair with Emily's mother during the same time.
As a result, Henry abducted Emily Reynolds transporting her to a property formerly owned by his family.
There, Special Agent Spade confronted him and when he would not surrender, shot him once to prevent injury to others specifically Emily Reynolds, who he was holding at gunpoint.
And this shooting, though unavoidable, proved fatal.
" Um, the timeline of the investigation is laid out in the report and incorporated by reference.
Agent Spade.
You didn't sign it.
Oh, sorry.
That's my fault.
There were some typos and I had to get it reprinted.
Oh.
Thanks.
We'll have the administrative part of this taken care of by the end of business.
Thank you, Agent Newman.
- Take care.
Thanks.
Sorry to blind-side you like that.
You made it impossible for me to tell the truth without getting you in trouble.
I know.
So did you get the bone-marrow test? I'm not a match, but they did an HLA test.
It looks good for my mom.
Great.
I was gonna tell the truth.
- I'm kind of tired of being stuck in this.
- But you're not stuck anymore.
You did tell the truth.
To me.
What do I do? I just forget about it? No.
You learn how to forgive yourself.
Forgive yourself so if you screw up, it's for something you do now.
Not for something that happened decades ago that you had no control over.
Is that supposed to be wise? No, not really.
I'm just not ready to see you leave yet.
I'm tired, Jack.
I know you are, honey.
Why don't you take a couple days off? I will.